Does this sound like a hypocritical or a stereotypical statement to you?

So a couple months ago, I showed my friend Death Note, and she loved it. Recently, while I was obsessed with Black Butler, I asked her if she would also watch it, and she said she hated animê (basically all animê shows). Then, a week ago, she told me to watch Vampire Knight, because she thought it was awesome.

So, do you think that she was being stereotypical for watching one or two bad animes and categorizing all animes as bad, or hypocritical for contradicting herself?