Honorable mentions to Bon Voyage and Those Are Strings, Pinocchio of Gilmore Girls.
And tons tons more, that I can't even name...

Fred's soul was consumed, she never even got to move on or exist in the after life. It was the most depressing thing ever. Her and Wesley and Spike and Angel and Gun D:

agree with SGI-090 that one always gets me as well as this one, both are just so out of the blue shocking (especially when you watch them first time round) snd so but there lives where just about to get great that i wana cry so much, the buffys ones you picked i find sad but arnt the buffys episodes that get me!

Whooops, I just realized I have top ten in the title and fifteen options :P Sorry about that!
What are the ones that get you, Kate?

I was torn between this & 5x10. I think, as much as i love Jo & Ellen, there is nothing worse to me than Dean dying.

I cried like a baby =[

I am a mess EVERYTIME I watch this

This episode was just SO heartbreaking. I cry like a baby every single time. Fred was my fave character :(

I also cry at;

The Gift
Help
Not Fade Away
Chosen
Hero

i cried like a baby.....especially when i hear the song "Hallelujah"

OMG I just rewatched this episode and I cried just as much as I did the first time I saw it. I'm tearing up just thinking about Wes' face while Fred is in excruciating pain and he`s helpless to stop it.

I think the only other episode of tv I've seen that makes me cry as much as A Hole in the World is Abandon All Hope. That one was even worse than No Rest for the Wicked because as much as I LOVE Dean, I knew he would be back. Same with Spike in Chosen, I knew he died and came back on Angel before I ever saw Chosen. No Rest for the Wicked and Chosen are still really sad though.

Others that make me cry are Hero, The Body, and Not Fade Away.

all those angel and btvs episodes make me cry!
it was really hard to choose the saddest. i think the gift makes me cry the most- but since i only cry at the very end of the episode when buffy dies, i chose the body because i cry hysterically throughout the whole episode every single time i watch it.
but i also cry soooo much everytime i watch a hole in the world...wow, this is a hard pick!

I just rewatched this the other day, and it moved me so much...
It could have had something to do with my neighbour's daughter finding her mom (the neighbour). I think you can clue in the rest.

& all the buffy/angel ones ♥