I love Peyton in every season the same<333 But I decided to go with season 1 as my favorite season of hers because its the season where I first fell in love with her♥ We got to see so many different and conflicted sides to her and thats what attracted me to her character in the fist place♥

Haley in season 1 is amazing. She was sweet, adorable, nerdy, and sarcastic and I adored her like that. I also loved the whole innocent vibe she gave off:)<3

Although season 2 sucked IMO, Nathan was amazing this season:)<3 We got to see his bad ass, IDGAF side but we also got to see his vulnerable heart broken side! I really wish they kept his character like this through out the whole show.

Season 6 Lucas was AMAZING<33 I know a lot of people don't seem to like him this season but for me he was perfect. He was finally done being conflicted and confused. He knew where his heart was and he knew what he wanted and that just made his character more enjoyable than usual:)<3 Plus he really redeemed himself form season 5;)

I really liked Brooke in seaso 5.I wish her character always stayed like this. She was sweet, mature, and didn't mess with people and didn't play games but we still got to see that fun side of her. It was a perfect mix:)

The season that I fell in love with her character <333

My favorite season for Brooke <33

i dont agree with any of this! hahah peyton.. well i never liked. Haley i love in every season but specially 3,4 and 9 same with nathan. Lucas i like in S1,2 and 3. Brooke i like the most in S3.

I either completely agree or somewhat agree with almost all of these.
Season 1 is my favorite Peyton & Haley seasons. But I decided to go with Peyton cause in season 1 she was probably my favorite character on the show, and as the seasons passed I just never loved her quite as much as I did in season 1. Where as my other favorite Haley seasons are seasons 7 and 8 and she's consistently been one of my 2 favorite characters on the show.

I love Nathan in season 2, but season 3 is my favorite season for him (probably followed by season 2).
Love Brooke in season 5 (but I prefer her in seasons 2 and 3...but 5 follows closely behind).

Only one I really disagree with is Lucas. I thought season 6 was his worst season.

Because this is the only season in which Lucas knew what he wants. I liked Lucas in every other aspect, but he was so confused when it comes to love. And it really annoyed me. So this season was great for him.

I also loved s1 Haley and s5 Brooke, but I loved them in almost every season. And I guess I agree about Nate, but I liked Peyton more in other seasons...

Or nathan season 2

I agree with all <333

<3

i like haley in 1 5 6 7 8 9
peyton in 1 3 4 6
lucas 1 3 5 6

I agree with all of these, Moosh :D

this was tough. close tie between peyton and haley.
i don't think i have a fave nathan season, but im pretty sure it wouldnt be s2.
im one of those ppl who didnt like luke in s6, imo it was his lowest season mainly because i barely noticed he was in it, he lacked presence. i can't think of one sl that was his for his sake alone.
i think brookes best seasons are 2,3,5 and 6. but i wouldnt be able to pick a fave.
so it was between peyton and haley because i liked the differences in them in s1, peyton was my favourite character and she's why i watched the show but the only 'bad' peyton seasons in my mind are 4 and 5.
with haley i really love her in season one, she had the quirkiness that seemed to be sucked out of her in later seasons, i love haley in some scenes in the later seasons after the time jump that really are bloody just haley terrific, but still there was this classic s1 haley that we don't get in any other season. so i guess i pick her, overall yeah my fave season of her would be s1. so i agree with ya there.