Yes because...
*She doesn't know she's his 2nd choice. No matter what we all see on the show, that might not be what she sees. Maybe she HASN'T realised Peyton is Luke's no.1 or maybe she's in denial. Either way, poor girl.
*She IS in love with him. Whether she gets the love back or not is another issue. But why wouldn't you say yes to someone that you love?
I wish she'd realise what an ass he is and get out, because she's so nice and she really deserves better.
It just annoys me that even though she knows Luke still has feelings for Peyton (how can she not know) she would still say yes. I understand that she loves him but how can she make that kind of commitment after everything?
Answering to Tinna, I think she knows and I like her too =P
I think Lindsey really believes Lucas is in love with her...what a dumb bitch. I would have said yes if I were her but under different circumstances. She sees how Lucas obviously isn`t over Peyton so she just accepted his proposal to hold on to whatever`s left of that pathetic relationship.
OKAY EW i swear if another burcaser nerdass types this "lindsey did NOTHING wrong" one more time i will come over there & slap your face off ugh so damn annoying
If she hasn't worked it out before now you have to feel sorry for the poor girl. Clearly she is extremely....erm.....what's a nice way of saying thick?
NO!
LINDSAY IS TOTALLY WRONG FOR LUCAS!PAYTON AND LUCAS ARE MEANT TO BE TOGETHER!
but i hate lindsay and i dont like lucas. he doesnt deserve a girl like payton anyways...
Lizisme, I dare you to start watching the show. We ALL realize that Lucas has been in a romantic relationship with Lindsey longer than the one he had with Peyton. That will never compare to the amount of years he has known Peyton. All the history they share, got it?
she definately has a right to say yes, but she has to know it's the not the right thing for her. she may not know that she's lucas's second choice, however she has to know that lucas still has feelings for peyton, and if she doesn't she's an idiot. and to be honest with you I think she does know but she's doing what she can to save a relationship because she really does love lucas. She's trying to fight for him, which is something he needs(one step above brooke i guess, brooke wouldn't even fight for him) anyway thats off topic. He may have offically been with Lindsey longer than he was with Peyton, but come on he's been with Peyton for a long time. They are meant to be together, and Peyton will fight for him, she's fought for him before, she'd do a lot for him, she already has throughout the seasons. I love Lucas, and I love Peyton, and he's being an ass right now and hurting Peyton, But Peyton's hurt him to she isn't innocent.
exactly Leyton4ever, I'm not questioning whether she had the right or not, of course she did, I'm just saying she wasn't right to do so because that's not how you hold on to someone
Lindsey did nothing wrong. She isn't stopping Leyton from happening, Lucas is stopping Leyton from happening.
Lindsey is in love w/ Lucas, who until Peyton came back, acted like he was totally in love with her too.
I think I big reason I like Lindsey, is because Haley likes Lindsey and she has a good judgement of ppl (usually) and she wants what's best for Lucas and she thinks it's Lindsey.
And Lila, I'd love to see you come and "slap my face off" you are so damn annoying too dissing everyone's opinion when it isn't a carbon copy of your own.
I think she has a right to say yes, but it's just dumb how she knows luke still has feelings for peyt, yet she's willing to go through a marriage! I would say yes if that was me, but if i knew that he had feelings for his ex than i wouldn't even be sure! But like i said, there has to be a catch to this proposal! Maybe lindsey found the ring and luke walked in on her looking at it than just i guess paniced and propose to her! That's what im thinking!
I couldn't agree more with tinna and elliesowner.. i don't want leyton to happen but the way things are going I couldn't care less what happens to luke..
oh and i totally agree with elliesowner on the lila thing, at first I thought she just needed some attention but it's getting a bit out of control.
Lila, calm down for once. What is it with you attacking the people that don't have the same opinion as you?
I am NOT a Brucas-fan, a Leyton-fan or a Lindsay/Lucas-fan for that matter BUT SHE DID NOTHING WRONG. Is it WRONG to fall in love? I feel sorry for you then.
YOU KNOW WHAT, YOU BRUCASERS ARE SUCH GEEKOIDS THATS ALL I HAVE TO SAY ALL UGLY & HAVE NO FRIENDS MOST LIKELY. EW. & ELLIESOWNER BOY I WOULD COME & SLAP YOU BUT I DON`T WANNA TOUCH YOUR UGLY HALEY-LIKE HEAD . & STOP COPYING EVERYTHING I SAY THEN SAYING IT BACK TO ME .
UGLY FATTIES YOU CAN GET BACK TO EATING YOUR TWINKIES NOW
Lila, you have serious problems. Why do you do this? Why do you yell at people that don't have the same opinion as you.
Many of the people that don't agree with Leyton aren't Brucasers so why are you attacking them?
You are one of the saddest persons I've seen on the internet.
Whoa Tinna. Two wrongs don`t make a right. It`s fine for you to have your opinion about Lila but it`s not fair to judge her either. I did call out a certain user but I can`t stand all the trouble they start on this spot. I already accepted that their life is so empty and they get a thrill out of being a troll on Fanpop. I just decided to ignore the loser and report them until my fingers bleed. Lila is a great girl with a strong opinion but that doesn`t give you the right to pass negative judgement on her.
And why does she have the right to pass negative judgment on other people? No.
I usually never say these kind of things but Lila has gone way over the line, calling EllieOwner ugly and calling all people that don't like Leyton "ugly fatties". For one, I never said I was a Brucaser but she still thinks I am even if I tell her I'm not. Just because I'm not a Leytoner.
I do not know ElliesOwner so I don't know if she's fat or ugly but neither does Lila. What gives her the right to be rude?
You call me on it but not her... hmm...
Some people just get their thrill when taking others down.. i'm sorry but lila has proven that's her way. I hate using the same arguments as lila but getting so mean and personal with people you don't know just proves you have problems with your own image and friends and definitely with having a life outside of fanpop.
Why not let those silly things slide and just be happy with your own opinion?
And I keep wondering who made you queen? Who decided you could choose between ugly and pretty? That's a lot of power you give to yourself, be careful with it...
"And I keep wondering who made you queen? Who decided you could choose between ugly and pretty? That's a lot of power you give to yourself, be careful with it..."
Seriously, seriously - do you think she actually means they are ugly or pretty??? No!!
It's just something people say when they're annoyed and i'm pretty sure she's refering more to personality - e.g she doesn't like you so you are ugly! god - you guys act like she's actually turning you ugly or pretty depending on her word. Don't go to far guys she's not magical or anything it's not like she can kill you with her mind.
"OMG what gives her the right e.t.c....."
She has the right to state her opinion despite your view on whether it is rude or wrong or whatever. Everyone keeps going on about how everyone can have their own opinions - WELL so can Lila.
You know exactly what I mean, it doesn't matter how you feel. Words can hurt peoples feelings and going around bashing everyone is good fooooooor.. WHAT? I don't really care about WHAT lila says. It's just annoying how almost every single comment attacks someone. She can state her opinion as much as she wants but this is still a public site and you should at least show some decency when commenting on someone else's opinion... apparently you didn't learn that either. You people just make it harder for those of us who WANT to stay friendly!
*She doesn't know she's his 2nd choice. No matter what we all see on the show, that might not be what she sees. Maybe she HASN'T realised Peyton is Luke's no.1 or maybe she's in denial. Either way, poor girl.
*She IS in love with him. Whether she gets the love back or not is another issue. But why wouldn't you say yes to someone that you love?
I wish she'd realise what an ass he is and get out, because she's so nice and she really deserves better.
Answering to Tinna, I think she knows and I like her too =P
I think Lindsey really believes Lucas is in love with her...what a dumb bitch. I would have said yes if I were her but under different circumstances. She sees how Lucas obviously isn`t over Peyton so she just accepted his proposal to hold on to whatever`s left of that pathetic relationship.
LINDSAY IS TOTALLY WRONG FOR LUCAS!PAYTON AND LUCAS ARE MEANT TO BE TOGETHER!
but i hate lindsay and i dont like lucas. he doesnt deserve a girl like payton anyways...
Lucas And Peyton True love always
Lindsey is in love w/ Lucas, who until Peyton came back, acted like he was totally in love with her too.
I think I big reason I like Lindsey, is because Haley likes Lindsey and she has a good judgement of ppl (usually) and she wants what's best for Lucas and she thinks it's Lindsey.
And Lila, I'd love to see you come and "slap my face off" you are so damn annoying too dissing everyone's opinion when it isn't a carbon copy of your own.
oh and i totally agree with elliesowner on the lila thing, at first I thought she just needed some attention but it's getting a bit out of control.
I am NOT a Brucas-fan, a Leyton-fan or a Lindsay/Lucas-fan for that matter BUT SHE DID NOTHING WRONG. Is it WRONG to fall in love? I feel sorry for you then.
UGLY FATTIES YOU CAN GET BACK TO EATING YOUR TWINKIES NOW
Many of the people that don't agree with Leyton aren't Brucasers so why are you attacking them?
You are one of the saddest persons I've seen on the internet.
I usually never say these kind of things but Lila has gone way over the line, calling EllieOwner ugly and calling all people that don't like Leyton "ugly fatties". For one, I never said I was a Brucaser but she still thinks I am even if I tell her I'm not. Just because I'm not a Leytoner.
I do not know ElliesOwner so I don't know if she's fat or ugly but neither does Lila. What gives her the right to be rude?
You call me on it but not her... hmm...
omg, she knows inside that Lucas is in love with peyton. She is just trying to split up Leyton for good .
Why not let those silly things slide and just be happy with your own opinion?
And I keep wondering who made you queen? Who decided you could choose between ugly and pretty? That's a lot of power you give to yourself, be careful with it...
"And I keep wondering who made you queen? Who decided you could choose between ugly and pretty? That's a lot of power you give to yourself, be careful with it..."
Seriously, seriously - do you think she actually means they are ugly or pretty??? No!!
It's just something people say when they're annoyed and i'm pretty sure she's refering more to personality - e.g she doesn't like you so you are ugly! god - you guys act like she's actually turning you ugly or pretty depending on her word. Don't go to far guys she's not magical or anything it's not like she can kill you with her mind.
"OMG what gives her the right e.t.c....."
She has the right to state her opinion despite your view on whether it is rude or wrong or whatever. Everyone keeps going on about how everyone can have their own opinions - WELL so can Lila.
Don't be so god damn hypocritical for god's sake!
Sign In or join Fanpop to add your comment