I swear to God if she is pregnant and it's not Finn's... I will flip out.

Knowing Glee....It's Finns but I would bet on Brody if she were my friend. (My only friend that has a baby that the daddy is unknown is between three guys.)

That would make more sense for me but I can bet she's not

Now if the question was "who do you hope the father of Rachels baby is?" I would say Finn, unfortunately the timing for when finn and rachel had sex just wouldnt make sense

This, in my opinion, was probably the worst decision Ryan Murphy has ever made. At first, I was just freaked out at the fact that Quintann got it on. Because, come one, nobody was seeing that coming. But Rachel being pregnant? ANOTHER GOD DAMN PREGNANT STORY!? No ....just no. I would have found it less alarming had Kurt gotten pregnant to Finn, or if Quinn had gotten so off her face on booze, mistaken Puck's hideous do for a comfy seat, and sat on his face! But this? This is bull D:<

Sorry for a stupd question, but I missed few episodes... Did Finchel have sex after break up and before "I do"? Even when they met in NY I don't really think they were in the mood... I don't know how much time passed until the end of episode since valentine's day, but Rachel needed AT LEAST 10 days - 2 weeks to suspect pregnancy after valentine's day, and it seemed to be 1-2 days after....So is it even possible for Rachel to be pregnant with Finn's child?

It's physically impossible for her to test a (true) positive from only being gone 2 days and have it be Finn's, and we know Brody and she have been sexually active (and this is a whole other mess with the whole whoring around buisness, if that's what he's doing) but this is Glee so making sense doesn't matter. I'm hoping it's just a false +.

If she's pregnant, it has to be Brody's. The timing doesn't fit with Finn at all. It couldn't have been from the wedding, because not enough time had passed for the test to turn out positive, and the last time they could have possibly had sex, would have been before "The Break up", which was in the beginning of October. So she would have been four months pregnant - and showing - by now.

Guys, Guys, Guys.... LISTEN. If you open your eyes and look very closely at the calendar Rachel Berry is holding, It states VERY CLEARLY that the month is MARCH. Thus, Giving it sufficient time for it to be Finn's baby. Also, If she has sex with Brody, Of course they will use protection (aka Condoms). Unlike when Finn and Rachel hooked up where it was UNEXPECTED. They most likely didn't use a condom. Come on, USE LOGIC. Didn't you see Rachel just slip her clothes right out. After that, Finn probably only thought about getting it in. Yeah, it won't give too much of a plot when she finds out Finn is the baby Daddy, But there's also the possibilities of miscarriage, Abortion (which I highly doubt cause a lot of people are against) and her not knowing who the baby daddy is... Even though its Finn. lol OKAY IM DONE

If they go down this road i hope it's the baby of the true love. Finn & Rachel!! She doesn't love Brody and Brody doesn;t love her.