If you were to HAVE TO remove 4 members from SNSD to form a 5 member group, which would they be?

Sr but I can't choose. SNSD must have 9 members. And I amor them all <3

no one! forever 9!

YoonA
Sooyoung
Seohyun
Sunny

The remaining 1:Taeyeon(cuz she is the leader)Yoona(the face of SNSD)Hyoyeon(the ultimate dancing queen)Jessica(2nd vocal) and Sunny(the aegyos queen)
Honestly..I don't want any of them to leave SNSD^^
I amor EACH MEMBER OF SNSD :D

Well I will choose:
1.Sunny(she is a good singer but there are 4 better singers and I think it's ok)
2.Tiffany(Yes,she is a awesome singer but 3 is ok)
3.Yoona(Even she is my favorito I think that she is a good dancer but...)
4.Sooyoung(She is a good dancer too but 2 are ok)

Seohyun (even she is my fave, i don't see at her something special/different)
Sunny (cute, but again nothing special)
Sooyoung ( Yuri and Hyoyeon are better dancers... and she isn't that good in singing)
Yuri (It was between Yoona and Yuri, but yYoona is the face of the group so...)

Honesty i want all of them to remove and no mais SNSD but i can't so here are my answer:
1)yoona because she is suck at singing!!
2)Hyoyeon because she is like the lest favorito in snsd and she can't really sing!
3)Sooyoung because she is not that good at cantar or dancing
4)Sunny because her voice is not that powerful!!

yoona, jessica, seohyun and sunny. cause i amor the 5 other members mais =)

i would remove :
1- Tiffany
2-yuri
3-sunny
4-jesseca

NONE!of them they r 9 anjos and they will always be,they r better 2gether and they complete each other and i don't think that snsd will be as powerful as they used to be if they disband a member so each one of them has something special so NONE!

Ehhh I really like snsd but I think if Hyoyeon,Seohyun,Tiffany and Sunny are a bit ...ummm.......boring? I'm so sorry Sones, don't bash me!

Yoona(just cute) Sooyoung(just dont like her) The youngest(dont know her name) and the 1 who can dance(dont know her name)

I prefer them as nine. But if I had to cut it down to four, I'd keep:

1. Taeyeon-She's the leader, best vocalist, and one of the most if not the most popular in Korea.
2. Jessica-She's a main vocalist, and she's popular. She speaks English and she has a different and interesting image.
3. Yoona-She is hated por many, but she's also the most popular. She also helped SNSD become mais well known because of her acting. If you cut Yoona out you'd be cutting a lot of their fanbase. Plus, she's beautiful and sweet. And her dancing is perfect for SNSD style dances.
3. Seohyun-She can sing and she could also be segundo dancer.

As for the others:

1. Sunny-She has a low fanbase, and while she's talented she doesn't stand out among the 8 other talented girls.
2. Tiffany-She's really sweet but she brings mais haters than Yoona does, and she's the weakest dancer. She could be a solo singer.
3. Hyoyeon-She can only dance, and her dancing style doesn't fit SNSD songs.
4. Yuri-Her live cantar is weak.
5. Sooyoung-She's a pretty good dancer and a fairly decent singer, but the others girls are stronger.

BUt I amor them all as 9 ^^

I would remove these members:
1. Yoona- Because even though she has a lot of fans, she also has a lot of haters. I think if she didn't have as much spotlight and attention all the time people wouldn't find her as pretty :(. I find her pretty, but most definitely not the prettiest. She has a weak voice too, so yeah :(.

Yuri-Yuri is an okay singer, and a good dancer. I only think there needs to be one dancer in SNSD though :(. Yuri can't hit as many of the tough dance moves as Hyoyeon.

Sooyoung- Sooyoung, in my opinion, doesn't have a very good voice. My sister agrees with me, and Sooyoung is her bias! Sooyoung is a good dancer, but like I said above, I only think there needs to be one dancer in SNSD.

Sunny- Sunny is a good singer, and great at aegyo but she is around the 5th best singer in my opinion, and I don't think there needs to be that many lead singers.

Just my opinion though :)!
So that would leave

Hyoyeon, Taeyeon, Jessica, Seohyun, and Tiffany :).

I would put Jessica and Taeyeon as main vocalists, Tiffany and Seohyun as the lead vocalists, and Hyoyeon as the main dancer.

This is soooo hard for me to say being a SONE cause I just amor them all :'(
but if I had to pick it would Tiffany, Sunny, Sooyoung and maybe Yuri? I don't know it's so hard for me to say this :(

I'm a sone and amor all but if I HAD too probably would be:
1.Yoona-Yes I amor her but she is known for her face not her cantar or dancing ability
2.Hyoyeon-Yes she can dance amazingly but her style doesn't fit SNSDs and she can't sing.
3.Tiffany-Can't dance, Taeyeon,Seohuyn,Jessica,Sunny can already sing and are better than her at dancing.
4.Sunny-She is known for being 'cute' like Yoona is known for her face, she can sing and dance but she doesn't push herself.

Tae- she's remain she's the power vocal STAY
Jess-the barbie preveals ,shereach high notes STAY
Sunny- she didn't shine lately and stylist gave her crappy hairstyle OUT
Tiff- i amor seeing her in a performance STAY
Hyo-good dance bad voice OUT
Yuri- too sexy, too much, i don't like her she is too forced attention lover OUT
Sooyoung- i lover her long legs but NO. OUT
Yoona- raised snnsd popularity, great dancer, and rapper STAY
Seohyun- she is boring, but they need her vocals and in a group their should be always the underrated one STAY :)
here you have it
Taeyeon
Jessica
Tiffany
Yoona
Seohyun

THIS IS MY PERSONAL OPINION.

1. Yoona (she probably has the least amount of talent in the group)
2. Sunny ( same reasoning as Yoona)
3. Sooyoung (same reasoning as below)
4. Seohyun (She is talented and I like her. But I agree that she has a lack of charisma, which is needed in a girl group)

-Yoona = she is pretty but definitely the weakest singer
-Seohyun= beautiful voice but also shy and a little bit boring
-Yuri = also pretty and a good dancer but a bit too quite
and the fourth one .. i don't know but we are all so know that snsd can only be with 9 members and that is good