If edward didnt choose bella , who out of any of the other women either in the family or girls at school do you think would have been good for him ?

i agree Alice and Edward would be a funny mix but he souldn't be with anyone else but Bella it wouldn't be right seeing him with someone else. unless the person was me. dream big

i don't think anyone was good for Edward.......Bella is perfect for Edward....... so i don't think he would have found anyone else......so Edward waited a while to find the right person to be with.

I think that I would pick someone that we don't even know from Twilight. Like some extra somewhere out there!

I think Alice, Rosalie is too high maintenance for someone like Edward.

honestly i dont think anybody would be as good as bella is for him nobody in the family is right and none of the girls at school would satisfy him either!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

i think jessica

Not Alice, because she loves Jasper. Not Esme, shes married. Not Rosalie because she doesnt amor him in that way. So probably I'd say either Jessica or maybe Jane? Jane and Edward would make a wicked combo ;) And Jessica is just way too obsessed with him :D

Jessica

I am going with Tanya
like always.

I actually wish there was somewhat of a "Westside story" going on.

Like, if Edward fell in amor with one of the lobo girls. Or Jacob & Alice fell in love.

There would be a whole lot of conflict.