Andy hopes his theater troupe’s production of Sweeney Todd will help him win back Erin. Meanwhile, Michael tries to not be jealous of the attention Andy’s getting, and Jim and Pam realize their babysitter’s incompetent.
Erin and Gabe invite the office over for a “Glee” viewing party. Michael deals poorly with hearing people call Gabe his boss. Meanwhile, Andy grows mais and mais jealous of Gabe’s relationship with Erin.