Once Upon a Time Season 5 Video: Can Hook Summon Dark Emma to Return? 

As seen in this sneak peek at the opening minute of

Season 5 — and as Ginnifer Goodwin and Josh Dallas told TVLine at Comic-Con — getting Emma back after she merged with the Darkness and thus became the Dark One isn’t as simple as commanding her via the dagger.

Once Upon a Time ‘Lost’ Scene: Rumple Goes Barking Up the Wrong, Evil Tree

Press play above to get the heroes’ assorted reactions to Emma’s tragic vanishing (including Regina’s distinct “Now Emma’s a

” POV) and find out why the dagger isn’t able to bring back the fallen Savior.

Ah! “Guyliner!” She called him “guyliner”. Evil Queen is forever snappy with her insults. Fingers crossed for S5 of OUAT. This show was gone downhill from me since mid-S2. The season was Pan was simply unbearable. The back and forth with Rumple (he’s good! but he’s evil! but he’s good with evil intentions! Nay! I say he’s evil with good intentions! Say what now?!) had me rolling my eyes so I’m hoping Dark!Swan will revitalize a show that I fervently loved in S1. I need some of that first season magic back desperately.

Somewhere along the line the writers decided Regina being a horrible, petulant jerk to everyone around her in all situations was a good character move. I think they think it’s “sassy”. It’s not. Watching her call Emma’s grieving loved ones names because she’s uncomfortable with guilt and her emotions are always the most important? Grow up, stop acting like a child. Maybe be a strong adult for your son, you know the one standing right there freaking out over his other mom disappearing. Regina’s “redemption” has been a joke, but now I can’t even enjoy her as a morally gray character, because she’s just mean and nasty all the time. She has no filter or self awareness. NOBODY should want to be Regina’s friend, she sure isn’t a good friend to anyone else. But she’s the writer’s pet, so everyone just puts up with her crap and no one can ever tell her to shut up for once. I give it 2 episodes max before someone is bending over backwards to help Regina or make her feel better about a situation that is entirely her fault.

I totally agree. They’ve really confused “sass” with out-and-out rudeness. Regina ruined that scene with her insults and made it all about herself instead of Emma’s parents and son and boyfriend and their pain. She didn’t even try to comfort Henry! I’m tired of them having Regina be a selfish jerk who insults everyone while at the same time act like she’s changed and is a hero. They try to have it both ways and it doesn’t work. They keep shoving Regina front and center even when she shouldn’t be on that particular occasion, and it’s really hurting the show and sucking screen time from other characters. I have such Regina fatigue. Why were Emma’s parents and son so far in the background in this scene? They should’ve been up there with Hook, not Regina.

Regina is just rude The name calling and so on. Saying Emma is a problem and that to in front of the ppl who love and just lost her – her parents, son and Hook. She didnt give care for Henry in that moment. Only one who looked at Henry was Killian, whilst he was summoning Emma.

I agree with you guys! I like Regina but come on is this really the time for her to start calling Emma’s loved ones names while they have just lost Emma? Anyway’s I totally didn’t like the way that Regina just acted in this scene, especially after Emma just SAVED her. I understand that the writers want Regina to be sassy, but that was just plain rudeness.

I’m so ineffably tired of the Sean McGuire and Colin O’Donoghue show, I’ll likely skip this season.

Ditto. Last season was such a struggle. I barely made it to the end. I probably will sit this season out as well.

Regina is just being insensitive! She of all people should understand what Hook’s going through and there is Henry with them, worried sick for his mother. Jeez.

I’m tired of her attitude, I don’t care if she’s feeling guilt.

Their reply isn’t surprising. They’re a known Hook apologist.

Wow It only took an hour for the Regina hate to start

It’s a fantasy show take it for what it is and enjoy people!

Once again Hook is a useless boy toy wearing guyliner.

Its just so heartbreaking for Hook. Losing his love again to the dark one. Becoming the very thing. Heartbreaking and also seems like this is the first time he has held the dagger and it happens to be with Emma’s name on it. :(

Poor Snowing and Henry too. Look at them and Hook. They have to find Emma.

Pure heartbreak and angst. My heart breaks for Emma, and Hook.

Hook will FIND Emma and also Henry, its what they do as does her family

Love Regina. She is the only reason I am still watching this show. Looking forward to S5 with both Regina and Robin Hood.

Nina Dobrev Says Goodbye to TVD\'s Elena During 2015 Teen Choice Awards

Teen Choice Awards 2015: Teen Wolf, Pretty Little Liars and More TV Winners

Teen Choice Awards: Sarah Hyland\'s Graceful Fall, Gabourey Sidibe\'s Empire Dance Break and More Best…

Food Network Star Finale Recap: And the Winner Is...

Grey\'s Anatomy Season 12: Cristina\'s Return, New Romances & More Wishes

1Food Network Star Finale Recap: And the Winner Is...123

2Reboot This: Stars, Producers Pick the Shows (Buffy! FNL! Golden…83

3Muppets Promos: Nathan Fillion Ogled by Miss Piggy, and More ABC…67

4Least Sexy Dance Ever? Will HBO Help or Hinder Big Bird? Was True…61

Once Upon a Time Season 5 Video: Can Hook Summon…

Food Network Star Finale Recap: And the…

Teen Choice Awards: Sarah Hyland\'s Graceful Fall…

Reboot This: Stars, Producers Pick the Shows (