full metal alchemist Pergunta
Which series and why? Brotherhood or FMA?
I would have to choose Brotherhood myself. But I want to know from you!
 |
EdElric posted over a year ago
|
|
next question »
|
|
|
full metal alchemist Respostas
 |
Dearheart said:
I'd say neither. The mangá will ALWAYS come out on topo, início for me. It's got all the depth and emotion of the first anime, and the strong plotlines and character growth of Brotherhood. It's the best of both worlds. And go figure - it came first! It's how the Law goes: the book is ALWAYS better than the movie...or animes, in this case. =P
If it were up to me, I'd squish the first half of FMA with the segundo half of Brotherhood. Then we'd have the perfect animê adaptation. Alas, I shall have to settle for a love/hate relationship with both. Either that, or pretend that certain parts of both animes don't exist. xD
|
|
 |
Animeanimal said:
I say FMA. Why? It has the "original" cast for the characters and has alot mais "heart" then the other FMAB. FMAB is just the same only drawn a bit odd (only my opinion) and minus the Nina episodes and has a COMPLETELY different ending. Plus if I liked brotherhood the best that means that i would be telling everyone that worked soooooooooo hard on the first one that I "didnt like their work" or at least thats what i would feel like :( As an artist I would feel totaly Betrayed if someone did a re-make of something I put my coração and soul into.......and Vic. When he heard that he would have to redo EVERYTHING that he had already done......can you imagine what that would feel like? He thought that he did an incredible job on the first one and he almost denied the brotherhood offer. I cant imagine and i dont ever want to slap someone in the face like that......
.........I wasnt trying to be mean or anything and I hope no one takes ANY offense to this, but that is truly what i feel and thats all.....
|
|
 |
Moonlight_Kitty said:
That would be like choosing between morango cake and morango ice-cream. They both have qualities that are similar, but enough of them are different to give each a unique feel to them. I couldn't choose between them. I fell in amor with the original series (it was one of the first animê i watched), but I like how they did brotherhood (how they stay true to the manga). In the end I guess it's all how you feel about it, to each one his own.
|
|
 |
pumpkinqueen said:
Brotherhood diffenetly, it gets you so much mais into the story. It's mais coração breaking and it even makes you cry more. There are mais character for you to love, you even bond mais with the character, and even the background storys are better. I'm sick of people hating on Brotherhood just because it's not the original. Umm...Hello!! It's baste off the Manga, so it is pretty much the origanal. I'm only on episode 50 of Brotherhood and I still think it's better. I mean, I do amor the first FMA. But Brotherhood just seems better to me.
|
|
