Should Rose have gotten in the water with Jack? pesquisa Results - titanic

What do you think? Place your vote!

(Placed your vote already? Remember to login!)

titanic Should Rose have gotten in the water with Jack?

567 fans picked:

No because the story wouldn't have been the way it is.

77%

Yes because then Jack would have lived

23%

iLOVEtitanic posted over a year ago

Make your pick! | next poll >>

75 comments

	ali22 picked No because the story wouldn't have been the way it is.: Wud u have got in the water with him? Sorry but i wudnt! posted over a year ago.

	iLOVEtitanic picked No because the story wouldn't have been the way it is.: i wouldn't have because he wouldn't have wanted me too. posted over a year ago.

	inmate62890 picked No because the story wouldn't have been the way it is.: then they would probably both be dead.... posted over a year ago.

	megloveskyle picked Yes because then Jack would have lived: I think they should of both rotated back in forth. posted over a year ago.

	milolover247 picked No because the story wouldn't have been the way it is.: She promised him that she wasn't going to die that night. Plus, he is the man, he's supposed to die for her! posted over a year ago.

	preppy_king_bee picked No because the story wouldn't have been the way it is.: umm...the question says should rose have got in the water with jack? not do u think rose should have given the floating door to jack? therefore how would rose getting in the water have saved Jack, it would just meant that they both die...tbh i think jack would have found something to keep him more out of the water or he and rose shud have shared the door...but its only a movie. posted over a year ago.

	sk8ergirl08 picked Yes because then Jack would have lived: um i think she should just went in the water with him and let him go on the door she had something on her and he didnt and that seems unfair to me what she did. if she really loved him she would of done it. posted over a year ago.

	shmalex picked No because the story wouldn't have been the way it is.: But they both DID try to get on the door! It wouldn't float and sort of flipped back, so Jack just let Rose have it. What was Rose supposed to do...commit suicide? posted over a year ago.

	Chlarkfan picked Yes because then Jack would have lived: i think if rose loved him enough she would have gotten in the water with him and they would have died together with them holding hands and kissing. It would have been more romantic and i still would have cried. posted over a year ago.

	_Beach_Bliss_ picked No because the story wouldn't have been the way it is.: although they should've took turns... posted over a year ago.

	amandaj picked No because the story wouldn't have been the way it is.: The story wouldn't be close to what it turned out to be if they both got in the water and died together or something, but they could take turns or something... posted over a year ago.

	hsm123 picked No because the story wouldn't have been the way it is.: She would die too and it would have a not good ending posted over a year ago.

	Zcali1 picked No because the story wouldn't have been the way it is.: He gave his life for her and she trusted him. That's so sweet. posted over a year ago.

	x-Kissez-x picked No because the story wouldn't have been the way it is.: No because it's what made the film. He died a hero! posted over a year ago.

	MiraclexBlazer picked No because the story wouldn't have been the way it is.: i would find a way for both of us yo get out of the water, haha but if there was noway both of us could, i would rather hed died posted over a year ago.

	kaylabeebee picked No because the story wouldn't have been the way it is.: why would you getting in the water make him live? posted over a year ago.

	pugluver30 picked Yes because then Jack would have lived: It just goes with their whole "You jump I jump" motto. posted over a year ago.

	FanDlux picked No because the story wouldn't have been the way it is.: She did it for him posted over a year ago.

	iluvjesse picked No because the story wouldn't have been the way it is.: Jack wouldn't have necessarily lived if she had been in there with him. They probably would have both died. You know whats weird, I'm watching Titanic as I type this. And its on TV, too. posted over a year ago.

	Selenaforever picked No because the story wouldn't have been the way it is.: she promised him she would live if she gotten in that would be what he wanted posted over a year ago.

	RORYnJESSfan picked No because the story wouldn't have been the way it is.: Then she would die too... what is the point of that??? posted over a year ago.

	MarianRobin picked No because the story wouldn't have been the way it is.: They would have both dead and Jack wanted her to live posted over a year ago.

	Tessz picked No because the story wouldn't have been the way it is.: Why would Jack have lived if Rose got in the water with him? If she got in the water too, they would both have died! I always wanted Jack to climb up on the wood too, he gave up so fast.. Maybe if he tried, they could both get on it :) posted over a year ago.

	missdee222 picked No because the story wouldn't have been the way it is.: if rose would have gotten into the water with jack she would be dead too and jack wanted her to do wateva she wanted to do with her life posted over a year ago.

	tooch picked No because the story wouldn't have been the way it is.: rose promised jack that she would do everything he told her to do, like have children, fly a plane, ride a horse and all that stuff. so she did it in memory of him. her love was true and there was nothing to break that. ♥♥♥♥ preppy_king_bee it was a TRUE story and was made into a movie. so its not just a movie. just to let u know :) posted over a year ago.

	Vikki12 picked No because the story wouldn't have been the way it is.: I wouldnt coz then the story wouldnt have a very good ending, it would be very fast and not suttle at all plus i would want to live lol :) posted over a year ago.

	hay-hop picked No because the story wouldn't have been the way it is.: erm... no! omg! the cold eek! bet it was freezing! and i liked rose! lol posted over a year ago.

	Courtney22020 picked No because the story wouldn't have been the way it is.: She promised him that she would live. posted over a year ago.

	elinochka picked Yes because then Jack would have lived: he should be live and she die :) mwahaha i am evil posted over a year ago.

	loisclarkalways picked No because the story wouldn't have been the way it is.: They would have both dead and He wanted her to live even if that ment giving up his life posted over a year ago.

	vichen picked No because the story wouldn't have been the way it is.: She promised him that she would live and get a family <3 posted over a year ago.

	JacknRoseforeva picked No because the story wouldn't have been the way it is.: i think tht if rose had gotton into the water the she would of died n i agree with tooch she did it in the memory of him ride a plane, have kids and get married but she NEVER forgot him she always had him close to her heart xxxxxxx posted over a year ago.

	OCFan123 picked No because the story wouldn't have been the way it is.: The story is sad, but its a great one, so it wouldn't be the same. posted over a year ago.

	titanicgirl13 picked Yes because then Jack would have lived: i hated it wen a good couple like them seperated i dont care wat he says i wood have gotten in posted over a year ago. last edited over a year ago

	aznpwincess picked No because the story wouldn't have been the way it is.: as much as i love jack, there wouldn't be an epic love story if he didnt die posted over a year ago.

	mhigs_69 picked No because the story wouldn't have been the way it is.: if they both died then , no one will narrate the story ..lol posted over a year ago.

	SMackedHard picked No because the story wouldn't have been the way it is.: I would get in...I wouldn't die w/out my love. Besides, the ship was sinking. They had no other choice but to get in or die. Too bad for Jack though... :[ posted over a year ago.

	titanicfan1 picked No because the story wouldn't have been the way it is.: If she went in they would of both died and that would be a horrible ending. If i loved somebody that much i would not be able to live without posted over a year ago.

	ded99 picked No because the story wouldn't have been the way it is.: How Jack would have lived if Rose have gotten in the water with him? They would freezen and died together! posted over a year ago. last edited over a year ago

	EalasaidWooster picked No because the story wouldn't have been the way it is.: Well, no, because then she would have died and there would have been no story! posted over a year ago.

	TitanicFreak1 picked Yes because then Jack would have lived: If I were Rose, if I would die, I'd want to die in the water with Jack. :) posted over a year ago.

	KateWinsletFan picked No because the story wouldn't have been the way it is.: How Jack would have lived? posted over a year ago.

	s-jb123 picked No because the story wouldn't have been the way it is.: no, jack wouldnt have lived at all, and then if rose died, there would be noone there to tell her tail, and thats pretty much the plot of the story, how rose tells the tale of how she was on the titanic and how she loved jack posted over a year ago.

	sugarcane15 picked Yes because then Jack would have lived: they would have died together,but still how can rose live with her self without jack posted over a year ago.

	o_0whisper0_o picked No because the story wouldn't have been the way it is.: then there wouldnt be a movie since shes the one telling it posted over a year ago.

	XxMrsDarcyxX picked No because the story wouldn't have been the way it is.: There wouldnt have been a film if Rose had gotten in to the water with Jack because the likelyhood is that she would have died too. So there would be no Rose, no Jack AND no multi oscar winning epic of a film. posted over a year ago.

	VintageSmile picked Yes because then Jack would have lived: Ok, the film is perfection. Wouldn't change a thing to be honest. But FanFiction really does make your imagination go crazy... So yeah, I would have liked them to go together. posted over a year ago.

	Drumplayer picked No because the story wouldn't have been the way it is.: we love the story foe how it is we should not try to change it its a true story remember posted over a year ago.

	Sirea1 picked No because the story wouldn't have been the way it is.: No, because his death wouldn't make sense! "Rose, please you have to live! Promise me that you will survive!" posted over a year ago.

	glezps picked No because the story wouldn't have been the way it is.: I'm glad Rose survived!!! posted over a year ago.

	LifesGoodx3 picked Yes because then Jack would have lived: I'm not saying that this is what I wanted, but it would have been more logical for Rose to go in the boat. posted over a year ago.

	sheepprncss3 picked No because the story wouldn't have been the way it is.: no…because then the movie wouldn't have existed because there would be no old rose to tell the story…and it wouldn't have been a special posted over a year ago.

	lexy2442 picked No because the story wouldn't have been the way it is.: no because then she might not hav found a new ture love posted over a year ago. last edited over a year ago

	mandali picked No because the story wouldn't have been the way it is.: No , because the story would have been same it had been posted over a year ago.

	Pastagirl picked No because the story wouldn't have been the way it is.: Plus, Cal would have Killed him and she could fell it in him when she was looking down at him..that something isn't right at all!!! Remember what Cal said to jack? "I always win Jack, one way or other" posted over a year ago.

	Whiff picked No because the story wouldn't have been the way it is.: She promised him, that she won't give up and survive! It's very important! posted over a year ago.

	RoseJackDawson picked No because the story wouldn't have been the way it is.: The story is perfect just the way it is and Jack wanted Rose to live,she promised him she will survive,so... posted over a year ago.

	anouk1998 picked No because the story wouldn't have been the way it is.: She would die...and she promised him to survive...♥ posted over a year ago.

	klaine_forever picked No because the story wouldn't have been the way it is.: If that happened, then the movie would make no sence, because old rose was telling everyone the real story. So if she died, no one would have ever found out posted over a year ago.

	dachshud picked No because the story wouldn't have been the way it is.: I think of them should have died together, I'll never let go right!!!!!!!!!!!!! posted over a year ago.

	DeniseAnne picked Yes because then Jack would have lived: Maybe if she had moved her ass a little bit away... -.- posted over a year ago.

	pandawinx picked No because the story wouldn't have been the way it is.: Whats the point? He was already dead. posted over a year ago.

	lithiumchickie9 picked No because the story wouldn't have been the way it is.: His sacrifice would've been a huge waste if she just got in too. His death was romantic anyway. <3 posted over a year ago.

	SahidBadal picked No because the story wouldn't have been the way it is.: story is not fully complete so we can't say anything posted over a year ago.

	kimpettyfer picked No because the story wouldn't have been the way it is.: Yes and No, she would have died. Not good ending oherwise. posted over a year ago.

	hellokitty199 picked No because the story wouldn't have been the way it is.: rose didnt get in the water because jack wanted her to live posted over a year ago.

	kerrirulesxx picked Yes because then Jack would have lived: he is $exy so wouldnt u so u can go 2 heaven and have children etc x posted over a year ago.

	mikulover98 picked Yes because then Jack would have lived: If rose would of got on the stupid life boat then jack would of had the door to lay on!! posted over a year ago.

	RoseLovesJack picked No because the story wouldn't have been the way it is.: Jack made her promise to live. He wouldnt have wanted her to get into the water with him. posted over a year ago.

	carlygrl15 picked No because the story wouldn't have been the way it is.: She promised to Jack that she would never let go. I, personally, didn't want either to die, but that's MY opinion. posted over a year ago.

	nyomineedslove1 picked Yes because then Jack would have lived: If he didn't get in the boat he would've died. When he didn't get on the boat he also died so whats the point. Rose couldn't live without Jack. It's true love. posted over a year ago.

	Shassie picked No because the story wouldn't have been the way it is.: @DrumPlayer The Titanic yes is a true story but the story of Rose and Jack were made up the writer just whipped up characters and made up a story to go with the story of the titanic posted over a year ago.

	titanic12 picked No because the story wouldn't have been the way it is.: I recently saw Titanic in bluray with James Cameron's commentarie and on this scene he said "Jack had more experience and knew that they couldn't both live but Rose didn't have as much experience and didn't know" so it's not Rose's fault that Jack died and Jack ought to protect her! posted over a year ago.

	HoltNLucy4Ever picked Yes because then Jack would have lived: I feel like both Jack and Rose would have lived and stayed together had Rose gone in the water with Jack. Even though Jack had more experience and let Rose be on the door, both of them would have been able to fit on the door. Jack and Rose would have survived and lived happily ever after. posted over a year ago.

	Emogurlforever picked No because the story wouldn't have been the way it is.: I feel like there was room on the door for the both of them. I know that the director, James Cameron didn't think so, but I think there was and so, I believe that they should have both sat there and not only Rose, even if it made Jack a gentleman. Of course, there had to be some sadness in the movie. It's Titanic, a movie based on the real thing so there had to be some drama at the end of it all. posted over a year ago.

adicionar seu comentário

titanic

titanic Should Rose have gotten in the water with Jack?

75 comments

Sign In or join Fanpop to add your comment

titanic more polls