Vampire Diaries: Paul Wesley, Candice King talk Steroline-threatening new amor triângulo 

Here’s the thing about being an immortal vampire who’s more than 100 years old: You have a lot of baggage. And by baggage, I mean relationships. 

, Stefan (Paul Wesley) has a history with one of Lily’s heretics. Specifically, he and Valerie (Elizabeth Blackmore) knew each other back in 1863 before the Salvatore brothers were forever changed by the love (and manipulation) of Katherine Pierce. And when Caroline (Candice King) learns more about Stefan and Valerie’s history, there’s a chance it could mess with things in her new relationship with present-day Stefan. 

Long story short: Things are about to get complicated. So when EW visited the

set, we got all three members of this new love triangle to talk about what’s to come with Stefan and his ladies.

\'Survivor\' host Jeff Probst breaks down the latest blindside

Death Grips announce new album, \'Bottomless Pit\'

\'Ant-Man\' director Peyton Reed in talks to return for sequel

\'Creed\': Michael B. Jordan and Sylvester Stallone talk \'Rocky\' legacy

\'Survivor: Cambodia — Second Chance\': And the eliminated player is...

\'Star Wars: The Force Awakens\' ultimate fan trailer pieces together all the footage we have so far

What did \'Back to the Future II\' get right about 2015?

\'Star Wars: The Force Awakens\': Decoding the new trailer, shot by shot

Secrets of the \'Star Wars: The Force Awakens\' poster