We have to admit that we're totally shocked. Of course, it's entirely possible that this entire tidbit was made up -- and it does seem way out of left field, and a whole lot less believable than the Penn/Blake romance. Plus, Sophia's rep is saying there's nothing going on.

But anything's possible on the set of OTH, it seems. And we know that TV romance has happened offscreen in the past, both on OTH and on tons of other shows.

We don't know what to make of this, so we'll let you speculate. Do you think Sophia and James are dating, or is this complete nonsense? And if they are dating, are they a couple you'd like to see more of?