If you could ask JK one pergunta about Severus, what would it be?

WHY'D YOU MAKE HIS DEATH SO aleatório AND INCONVENIENT. Bitch...

If she ever toyed with the idea for the story of Harry finding out the truth before Severus' death so they could have had a little time to know each other. (at least for Severus to have a few days of being appreciated for who he really was instead of being alone)

Was it hard to kill Severus knowing everything she knew, or was it something she always had to do?

*Sob*

I guess something that would let me know mais about him as a normal person, like 'what's his favourite book?' or 'what does he do for a hobby?'

I would like to ask her if Severus ever killed someone if yes who? and when? Cuz when he was young (20) he was a Death eater. You never know he might have done it.

I would ask her why did you choose to make Severus the most complex character (in my opinion) and why she gave him such an important role in the life of the Potters.

I would ask her if she felt the same way about him, like some of us on here do. If she thought he was truly the hero of the story and if it wasn't for him, none of what went down could have been possible.

I would ask her about a theory of mine : Did Dumbledore compel Severus to make an Unbreakable Vow with him, to ensure his loyalty ? (You know, right after Severus went to see him about the prophecy and the threat to Lily Evans Potter.) If yes, who was their Bonder ? (OK, that makes 2 questions... LOL)

I support that theory as I'm always moved when Dumbledore replied to Harry : "I trust Professor Snape completely", as if the same Professor had pledged his loyalty with his own life. Like in an Unbreakable Vow. Sounds plausible in my opinion. I use it in my fanfics, whenever applicable.

I'd probably ask if Severus had any feelings of friendship for anyone other than Lily. He deserves to have a friend, someone who cares. And when I say friends, I mean, friends, not fellow Death Eaters.

x

I'd ask her how could i make Sev happy, and how come she made Sev's life so miserable X(

I think I would ask what happened to his parents, what kind of wood and nuclear his wand was (yes, I mean that wooden one) or what was it like to write his death and memories. I know, not very imaginative questions, but I'd like to hear these ones.

Why his patronus became a deer and not a stag. Did that mean he only really loved her as a friend? Or is this just wishful thinking on my part because I hate the SS/LE pairing?

"I, personally, would ask if he ever blamed his mother, or was angry with his mother, for staying with his father."

Good question. After a great deal of thought, and a great deal of reading, I realized today what I would ask JKR.

What ano at Hogwarts was Severus when his mother died, and was his father responsible for it?

No, my pergunta isn't baseless; there's a hint in one of the novels. I won't say which one or what the hint is. But it's there.

If I thought I could handle the answer, I'd ask her how physically abusive Tobias was to Severus when he was a child. Physical abuse suffered in childhood leaves mental and emotional scars that last forever. Tobias was a Muggle and clearly one of the worst kind; Eileen was a witch abused por him; this is what Severus saw every dia throughout his vital "formative years". That would certainly be one of the reasons why he is such an angry man.

Was there anything at all in his childhood that ever made him happy, like a beloved familiar. What little she reveals shows an unrelentingly miserable existence.

At the risk of sounding immature and sex-obsessed...I'd ask if he died a virgin or if not, when was his first time ;)

Why did you make Snape where he thinks that he should be forgiven for being a death eater and killing innocent people and being the reason for many people's deaths, but he can't forgive James Potter and Sirius Black for a school yard rivalry? I understand that it was over Lily but really why couldn't he just get over it? Oh and this isn't a pergunta but the only reason Dumbledore likes Snape on my opinion is because they are so much like each other; both were evil then turn good because of love.