All of them were pretty bad.. =/
But i have to say that what Haley did at Nathan in season 2 was the worst for me. It broke my heart watching her leave with Chris and Nathan being left alone.. And that really afected him. I think, considering this list, that he was the person who suffer the most because of the other half actions.
Peyton kissing Lucas twice and Jules lying to Keith was really bad too.

deb SLEPT with someone else when she was still married....and worse...it was with dan's brother!. that goes to a whole new level. Kissing is bad...sex with your husband's brother is insane.

I know we don't really care as much for the secondary characters, but ask yourself this simple question: what would hurt me more? Finding out my boyfriend/fiancé kissed another girl (even if it was twice)? or finding out my husband SLEPT with another woman? If my guy kissed another girl it would HURT; however to be fair, [I dunno about you guys, but] sex is a whole other level of cheating.

all of them were bad
but i choose this one because lucas proposed to lindsey on this nite to which is pretty sucky if u ask me

I don't think that Haley kissing Chris is as bad as some of these.
Haley didn't like Chris, Chris kissed her (and yes, she didn't pull away) but we ALL know she didn't have feelings for him; she just wanted to chase after her dreams and, hell yes it was a bad desision but she felt bad and she admitted to her mistake. Now, I was so dissapointed with her for leaving Nathan in such a depressed state but I forgave her for it. It was sooo wrong, but she was young, confused, scared and just wanted to sing.

Brooke sleeping with Chris, she was drunk and they weren't officially together.

Jules lying to keith was a mistake, but she ended up paying for it in the end because she really did love him and she had to leave him.

Nathan kissing Carrie was a mistake, but Carrie kissed him, he didn't really do anything.

Deb cheating on Dan wasn't a mistake at all, DAN IS AN ASS to start with, she was confused and drunk, and they were going to get divorced. Plus, she APOLOGIZED. Now, I hate Deb but I can't blame her for this. But, Keith was at fault in this situation.

Lucas kissing Peyton and then proposing to Lindsey was AWFULL. DEPRESSING. HEART BREAKING. But, I think that Lucas was just afraid. He didn't want to be close to Peyton so he proposed to lindsey. It was a gross thing to do, but Peyton was CHEATING with Lucas for what, the third time? I think that's pretty cruel.

Brooke sleeping with nathan wasn't bad at all. It was simply no attatchments sex. The Peyton, Brooke, Lucas love triangle was much more emotional, and Peyton had broken up with Nathan. And all their relationship was was a string of petty little breakups and makeup sex. Now, I love peyton, but I also love brooke, and I have to be honest, she did nothing near the level of betrayel that peyton had with her little cheating thing...

I HATED rachel for playing with Mouth's feelings, because I have to admit, I still grow soft on mouth. Plus, in that season I HATED rachel. And the whole cooper/rachel relationship was pointless and stupid.

Now, for my finale, Peyton cheating on brooke was the biggest mistake of her life. And, it was also the best thing she did. She ended up with Lucas, but she put herself first infront of her best friend who had ALWAYS been there for her. I know she cared about Lucas but that was just wrong on SOOO many levels. She betrayed her best friend's trust and acted carelessly and was heartless. I love her now, but I'm not going to say that what she did wasn't a big deal. It was wrong.

All these people made mistakes, but they are ALL great people now (except for Carrie, ofcourse, and Lucas... well, he's getting there...)

i could pick pretty much any of them...

it has to be this for me coz deb was wrong but she was in a unhappy marage and was goin through a divorce haley was hapily maried she had no reason to

How about Lucas cheating on Brooke twice? Because if we're saying that Peyton kissing Lucas is cheating (well i'm not crazy annoying people are) then by proxy Lucas not pulling away makes him a cheater doesn't it - which means he cheated on Brooke TWICE!

And the first time it happened with Peyton and Lucas Peyton tried SO hard to think of Brooke and put her first but the guy she LOVED kept chasing her and practically BEGGING her to be with him. That makes him WAY worse than Peyton - at least she was trying to think of Brooke he didn't give a rats ass - so why isn't he up there? Oh yeh i FORGOT because it's totally NOT Lucas's fault - UGH i'm so pissed of right now!

And i'm sorry 1treehillfan but i gotta do this :] I have rewrote what 1treehillfan wrote about Peyton Brooke and Lucas to be about Haley Nathan and the singing career she put before Nathan.


Now, for my finale, Haley cheating on Nathan was the biggest mistake of her life. And, it was also the best thing she did. She ended up with an amazing singing career, but she put herself first infront of her husband who had ALWAYS been there for her. I know she cared about Nathan but that was just wrong on SOOO many levels. She betrayed her husband's trust and acted carelessly and was heartless. I love her now, but I'm not going to say that what she did wasn't a big deal. It was wrong.


Any who i just thought as i was reading that went with Haley rather nicely =P

I know Nathan was abit rocky at the beginnng of the ship with Haley but you gotta admit after that he was pretty amazing and if your saying that Brooke sleeping with Peyton's ex-boyfriend of what? five minutes(when she knew that they would get back together anyway -because well thats what they did) isn't wrong and means she was ALWAYS there for Peyton i'm saying Nathan starting of as a jerk qualifies him for ALWAYS being there for Haley.

SG1-090, the reason why i choose to put "Peyton kissing Lucas twice" and not Lucas kissing Peyton was because i think Brooke was more upset with Peyton than with Lucas.
I'm not saying that it was only Peyton's fault, i know that she felt bad for kissing Lucas. Both Lucas and Peyton did wrong, but Peyton was Brooke's best friend since ever. Lucas did not only cheat on Brooke, but did it with her best friend.
Brooke was hurt by the two people she most loved. And normally in a situation like that, you need support from your best friend. But Brooke couldn't have that, because it was Peyton that had hurt her!

On the "Brooke sleeping with Nathan" i made the same choice, because Peyton was more upset with Brooke that she was with Nathan.

I'm sorry if you don't agree with that =/

wat a lil whore

um...peyton and nathan wasnt goin out when brook had sex with him so..that wasnt really bad

No man i think Nathan was just as bad as Brooke - for sure!! But EVERYONE KNOWS Nathan was a complete jackass - where as lots of people act like Brooke was a really good friend which she wasn't!

Brooke might have been more upset with Peyton - even though she said she was falling for lucas (but whatever) that doesn't mean it makes it more Peyton's fault and i actually think Lucas doing that to BOTH Peyton and Brooke is the worst......

I never said that it was Peyton's fault. It wasn't just her. I agree with you, Lucas was terrible with Brooke and Peyton. He never knew what he truly wanted.

I put "Peyton kissing Lucas twice" like i could had put Lucas kissing Peyton twice. They both cheated on Brooke.
But when i look back on what Brooke suffered because of them, like i said before, i think she was more upset with Peyton.

Although Brooke was falling for Lucas, he was just a guy! Boys are all the same, its the friends you have to keep close. :)
I am NOT taking sides. I'm not on Lucas side and i'm not defending what he did. Please don't get me wrong.

But if it's not more Peyton's fault then like i said why isn't Luke cheating on Brooke an option? Or even Lucas cheating on Brooke with Peyton then Lucas cheating on Peyton with Nikki?

BUT he wasn't JUST a guy in this circumstance he is Peyton's true love and someone Brooke said she was in love with - and he had claimed that he is the one true guy for both girls so i don't think saying it's worse when the friend does it because the guy was - just a guy - counts in this instance.

that almostt cost them a divorce.

ok, how can you put a kiss before sex? you can forgive sex and not a kiss, really?? plus, deb was cheating with none other than dan's brother! not a random person, her brother-in-law! how can you top that? so what if she was drunk or dan's an ass? that doesn't make it an excuse...like abs said, it's a whole other level of cheating

I’m sorry that Lucas cheating on Peyton with Nikki isn’t a option, but to be honest with you, i don’t really remember season 1. But i think that when Lucas slept with Nikki he had recently broken up with Brooke. He was a jerk, but he didn’t cheat because he was alone then.

About Lucas cheating on Peyton with Brooke not being a option it’s because i thought it would be repeated, and that didn’t make sense for me. The situation it’s the same and eveybody knows what happened.

It’s like Deb cheating on Dan, by sleeping with Keith. Keith sleeping with his brothers wife is equally bad. But i didn’t add it as an opition because it’s the same act. I thought it would be pointless.

But i will add the Lucas kissing Peyton option now.

thnx i DO get where you are coming from - honestly =] - it just annoys me when fans talk about how peyton cheated with Lucas but they never seem to realise/except that Lucas not only kissed peyton but he literally chased her while he was with Brooke i guess that's what i was trying to say was worse! =]

No problem! :) I get your point too.

Lucy, I think alot of ppl are picking what situation hit them the hardest. no one will deny that sex is worse than a kiss, but no one cares. most ppl hate dan so they think he deserved it. but if you put what happened afterwards...the situation was the worst. It drove the wedge even further between dan and keith - which led to dan's conspiracy with jules to break keith's heart in s2, it catalyzed dan's cooperation with the divorce, and it inadvertently caused his heart attack. I really don't care about dan and deb, but I know it was the worst (from the consequences and relationships affected). I don't expect ppl to agree with me though :).
Personally, the Luke kissing peyton then proposing to lindsey hit me the hardest; but that isn't what the question is asking.

c'mon!! LUCAS IS THE JACKASS!! Can't believe we still blame the girl... she should've stopped him, should've told brooke... But who is really to blame here?! Lucas! he's the only line in almost all the choices here. We girls should stick together and ban that crapbag from oth :D !!

... you fall in love with someone just to find out it was never what you thought! Which is what happens with most of the other choices too but this made me really sad!

yeah, abs, i'm with you on that..plus, dan killed keith in the end..i'm not sayin' that's the reason why he killed him, but it didn't help either..

totally agree with SG1 - i thought the only option given for the L/P/B thing was the peyton kissing luke one!! HELLO LUKES FAULT! LUKES A MAN WHORE BASICALLY CHEATING ON NEARLY EVERYONE! AND CAUSE PEYTON GETS INVOVED IN THE AFFAIRS LUKE HAS SHES TOO BLAME! ITS NOT HER FAULT SHES FUCKIN INLOVE WITH HIM IS IT!

AND IF IT WAS THE OTHER WAY ROUND AND BROOKE WAS THE ONE IN THE AFFAIR WITH LUKE CHEATING ON PEYTON THEN YOU WOULD ALL BE DEFEDING HER AND SAYING IT ISNT HER FAULT ... DONT SAY YOU WOULDNT CAUSE NOBODY WILL BELIEVE YOU, YOU WOULD DEFEND BROOKE 100% SAYING THE EXACT SAME THINGS WE HAVE BEEN SAYING SINCE THIS WHOLE BL VS LP THING STARTED!

You already said that nobody will believe, but believe it or not, the truth is that if it was Brooke the one in the affair with Lucas, cheating on Peyton, i would not be defending her!
It's NOT about the characters or the couple. God, i love all of them! It's about the act! I would not be defending a person who cheated on her best friend.

But you know what? I'm not blaming Peyton either. But you can't just say it was only Lucas fault! I'm sorry, i don't agree with you on that. Lucas and Peyton were both conscious and they both knew what they were doing. Peyton was in love with him, but Lucas also had a thing for her since ever! Maybe he's the one to blame more, because after all he was the boyfriend. But Peyton isn't innocent in that too.

And i am not in the whole "war" BL vs. LP. I am a Naley and a Brucas fan, but i also like Leyton. I like Lucas and Peyton together. I was including the two of them on the choice, because everyone knows the situation and know what happened. It was both Lucas and Peyton fault and i never thought that it would matter who was the more "guilty". So putting "Peyton kissing Lucas twice, while he was dating Brooke" didn't have any intention or something. I actually never thought it would be such big deal.

WOO WOO! HOLD ON A SEC I WASNT AIMIN AT YOU ABOUT THE 'IF IT WAS THE OTHER WAY ROUND' - IM AIMING AT A FEW BLFANS THAT I HAVE IN MY HEAD THAT LIKE BUMB UP TO BROOKE AS IT IS - THE TYPE WHO MAKE COMMENTS TO PISS OFF SOME OFF US!

I NEVER SAID IT WAS ONLY LUKES FAULT YOU TWISTING MY WORDS .. I SAID LUKES FAULT! NOT ONLY I JUST SAID LUKE FAULT! A PICK WAS MADE SAYING WHOS FAULT WAS IT FOR B/L/P AFFAIR! LOADS OF PEOPLE JUST PICKED PEYTON AS IF LUKE WAS INVISABLE AND NOT EVEN AN OPTION! I PICKED THE OPTION THAT SAID ALL 3!
BROOKE - KNEW ABOUT LP, KNEW THERE WAS SOMETHING THERE BEFORE SHE STARTED DATING LUKE! NOW SHE PUT HER HEART IN TO GET HURT BEFORE SHE LET LP PLAY OUT!
PEYTON - SHE GOT PULLED IN CAUSE SHE WANTED LUKE SOO BAD .. AND BY GOD SHE KNOWS IT CAUSE SHES GOT SOO MUCH STICK AND BASHING BECAUSE OF IT! THATS WHY I TEND NOT TO PUT THE BLAME ON PEYTON SO MUCH, CAUSE I KNOW IT WILL START PEOPLE IFF WITH THERE 'I HATE PEYTON'
LUKE - HE WAS THE ONE THAT PULLED PEYTON IN 'I HAVE TO BE WITH YOU'! HE WAS THE ONE IN THE RELATIONSHIP! PEYTON WAS INVOVED IN THE AFFAIR - LUKE ACTUALLY CHEATED!

I WASNT PINNING MY COMMENT AT YOU - JUST THOUGHT ID LET YOU KNOW! I WAS TALKIN IN GENERAL!

Okay sorry, i really thought you were talking only to me ^^
I don't remember if i saw that pick about the B/L/P affair and whos fault was, but if i had to picked one, i would never pick only Peyton. But i'm not sure if i would pick the 3 of them. I don't think Brooke was "guilty". She might knew about the whole LP thing, but i think that, in the beginning, she probably didn't thought that her and Lucas would become serious. She probably never imagined that she would love him so much.

Haley didnt cheat, it was one kiss and she went on tour for her music, not because of chris keller.

There all pretty much as bad as each other where the cheatings concerned

THEY WERE MARRIED DAMN IT!

This is the key sentence for me .. Sex is a whole other level of cheating than a kiss.