I think Lucas would be a good dad so would Nathan

i think lucas just isn't stable to be a dad he keeps switching from peyton to brooke to peyton and then in the 5th season it has been said hes going back to brooke! its getting annoying that he's switching them~

yeah, but just 'cause he switches between girls, doesn't really mean he wouldnt make a good dad.
i think they'd both make amazing dads.
in the 4th season they're only like 18 remember.

i wouldnt want either of them to be my dad.....because i think both of them are sooo hot so that would be kind of weird....

good poinnt miss73 :)

I don't wanna Nathan as dad; rather as boyfriend!!

lucas rather than a older brother

'Cause I'd rather want to look at Nathan in a wayyyy different way

Nathan is too hot .. No way would i want him to be a dad .. he's better for other things ;)

I don't like Luke, and I would love to have a dad like Nathan. But just a dad LIKE Nathan, not Nathan. 'Cause.. Well.. He's gonna be my boyfriend :D

Nathan's way too sexy to be my dad. LOL

okay that was a hard one. They both would make amazing fathers