DR76 I don't see why Emma's love life should be so important.

Evilregal14 This is good although I don't think Hook actually LOVES Emma, he just flirts with her.

Darkangel6 I see where you're coming from and I'm a captain swan shipper. But when it comes down to it, Emma might end up with Neal if he's on a mission to find her.

DR76 Again . . . who cares? If Emma had been a man, would fans be making such a big deal over what female "he" would ship with?

minervadawn ^ um.. Why are you so insistent on letting me know that you don't care. If ships aren't your thing. Then good for you. I respect that. So why do you keep coming back to this article and repeatedly tell me that you have no interest in what I have to say?

merdziiikaa I personally ship SwanFire more but I understand why people ship Captain Swan despite the fact that I don't really like the pairing. :) And you DR76 should really chill out a bit. Like minervadawn pointed out.. We got it the first time.

TDDD I'm such a CS shipper, especially in Season 3 when Hook changed his approach to Emma. I must be one of the few people who never shipped Gremma or even liked his character. I actually had such an issue with him. =P Let me explain. He made terrible choices and behaved abominably in the episode where he died toward Emma. He threw a dart right beside her head across Granny's Diner and easily could have hit her with it, perhaps even killed her. I don't appreciate relationships where a supposed 'Good Guy' endangers the life of he person he loves because her attitude is pissing him off. Also, just after this, he kisses her without her permission. He had no right and I'm so glad she called him out on this and told him that it was out of line. They were not in a relationship, and he was her boss, completely inappropriate. i'm also on Emma's side in regards to Graham sleeping with Regina in the same house as Henry and sneaking around to do it. I suppose after all this I wasn't too keen on the kisses at the end where Emma seems like she's going to give a relationship with him a shot. In my mind he had a lot to make for before they got to that point. And then, of course, he died, so that coupled with everything else put an end to any inclination to ship them.

minervadawn @TDDD Hook tried to kill Emma too and was also very rude throughout season 2, to the point of sexual harassment. If someone said the sort of thing he did to me. e.i. "i do like a woman an her back" while he was pinning me to the ground and "when I stick you with my sword you'll feel it." I would has no intrest in pursuing any sort of relationship, business or casual and particularly not romanic. He has become much more of a gentleman in season 3 so I have begun to really consider he as a possible match for Emma. However it is to soon for me to respect her if she went out with him right at this moment. Graham sleeping with Regina in the same house as Henry is the most ridicules argument people use against him. You don't think your parents ever had sex with each other when you were in the house? You think they didn't sneak around pretending it didn't happen when they did? This argument is made by people who still remain at least partly under the haze of blissful childhood ignorance, as far as "parents don't have sex".

FlightofFantasy I loved Emma and Graham and was heartbroken when he died. Then I started shipping Emma with August and he got turned into a little kid. Now I don't even care who Emma's with. I don't really care about any of her ships. And yes, the whole "'Graham and Regina slept together with Henry in the house!" thing is ridiculous. My parents slept together with us in the house; so did yours. Once they'd split up, they slept with their respective boyfriends/girlfriends/husbands/wives with us in the house; so did yours, if your parents split up and moved on. News flash: parents have sex! With each other! With other people! In the house! While you're there! Who cares? I walked in on my dad and his girlfriend when I was a kid; it didn't scar me for life.

minervadawn @FlightofFantasy I could never ship wooden swan for the same reason I cant do golden queen. In both ships one character manipulated and used the other ruining their lives in the process. This is not the foundation for a healthy relationship.

TDDD @Minervadawn My views on the scene at Lake Nostos sort of waver. I don't really think Hook tried to kill Emma, and she certainly gave him enough opportunities to in that sword fight. He wanted to win of course, but if he could do so without killing her he was going with that option. They were on different sides in a battle to get what they most desperately wanted and she had already wronged him terribly. It you take the interpretation that he was trying to kill her, he has a point in his favour over Graham in my eyes that there was a more legit reason for such an action. He wanted to get what he spend 300 years striving towards and Emma had already betrayed him, Graham, on the other hand, was annoyed at Emma because she was, quite rightly in my mind, pissed off at him. The difference I see between Hook and Graham, and many people will say this doesn't matter but it does colour my view, is that Graham was very obviously portrayed as a good guy. Hook was not. I don't think he was ever really a bad guy, but he wasn't a good one either. I believe deep down he's a good man, but not one of the 'good guys'. He very much played the part of an antagonist in the second season and while he was seducing/pissing off Emma, he wasn't trying to establish a relationship with her. Graham was, very clearly, courting her, all the while having sex with Regina. It's not the fact that Regina was having sex in the house with Henry, but the sneaking around irritated me. It may sound a little ridiculous but I felt as though they were acting like horney teenagers, as opposed to mature adults with great and important responsibilities, such as raising a child, running a town, and being the town's entire police force. I'm all for Regina having sex, but the way it came across to me frustrated me a little. What I don't like is that Graham was running around having sex with Regina while flirting with and courting Emma.