once upon a time

responda esta pergunta

once upon a time Pergunta

Am I the only person who thinks Snowing should be the guardians of Henry?

My friend and I were discussing this and we decided that if Storybrooke actually obeyed the law, Snow and Charming would be given custody of Henry. Legally Emma has no right to Henry, she already gave him up. Regina is not in a fit state of mind to care properly for an eleven ano old child. Re-watching Season 2, I have to say that I think Snow and Charming were the best guardians he had, their interactions with him the most healthy and caring. Legally, after Regina and Emma they would be seguinte in line as guardians for him.
 TDDD posted over a year ago
next question »

once upon a time Respostas

Evilregal14 said:
Snow and Charming are idiots they can't look after shit. Since the charmings always dump Henry on Ruby or Granny they are the most fit to look after him. Family member wise, Neal was hardly there half his life, Emma has no legal rights to him. Regina would probably be best since she is showing mais amor for him in season 2/3
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
Regina is not in a fit state of mind to look after an eleven ano old boy. She's just not. She struggling from a serious addiction. She has abandonment issues and has killed and destroyed the lives of a hell of a lot of people. That doesn't mean I don't think she can be a good mother but she's not now. For the first ten years of Henry's life he was and felt neglected. Regina has been showing mais amor lately but in a very erratic and obsessive way. Just because that's the only way she knows how to amor doesn't mean that's enough. A child needs mais than love. He needs a healthy parental amor and stability. They do not need to feel as though they have to pull their guardian through tough times, it's simply not healthy. I don't know what you mean about Snow and Charming leaving Henry with Ruby and Granny all the time, as far as I can tell they haven't done that at all unless they have other business to take care of. And that's what Ruby and Granny were, a temporary babysitter, while the Charmings went out and did very important jobs.
TDDD posted over a year ago
*
best answer lol
Alchemistlover posted over a year ago
minervadawn said:
Technically Cora would be seguinte in line if she wanted him because the adopted family generally has custody rights over the biological one. However since Cora is also crazy and there is no one else left in her family custody would go to Neal. If they couldn't find Neal then he would go to the Charmings. Of course nothing involving custody is ever this simple that is why custody battles can get so messy.

I do agree though that of all the charming/mills/stiskin clan Snow and Charming are probably the best parents.
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
The law doesn't know Cora is crazy, plus she was able to look after Regina. I would choose Ruby she always has him :P
Evilregal14 posted over a year ago
*
... And look how Regina turned out.
TDDD posted over a year ago
Alchemistlover said:
No i honestly think Regina, Emma and Neal can handle it and of course his gran parents can help to. Henry obviously wants to be with Emma and now Regina to fortunately.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
next question »
Cookies help us bring you Fanpop. By using Fanpop, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More Got It!