I like our current icon though.
Before doing any picks to choose a new icon would it not be better to have a forum where spot members can submit potential icons first?
I know you have the allow fans to add option on, but not only are ones added later less likely to be seen, this way each user can only add one option, when people may have seen multiple icons they think would work.
Besides, hopefully getting people interested in putting forward icons might get people interested in a spot update in general, which I think might be nice, especially given the amount of new Narcissa shots we now have to work with :)