Do you think (If James hadn't existed) Lily could have loved Severus in the same way he loved her? - be honest pesquisa Results - harry potter

What do you think? Place your vote!

(Placed your vote already? Remember to login!)

harry potter Do you think (If James hadn't existed) Lily could have loved Severus in the same way he loved her? - be honest

69 fans picked:

51%

Yes

49%

Sallymagi posted over a year ago

Make your pick! | next poll >>

17 comments

	zuntiz picked No: I think she loved him as a friend, but I don't think it would turn into a romantic love. posted over a year ago.

	MissAngelosonic picked Yes: Of course because of the friendship they had. posted over a year ago.

	Poseidon3 picked No: Possibly. But it wasn't James that caused their friendship to go downhill, it was Snape's love for the Dark Arts. Had he not been so interested in the Dark Arts she might have fallen for him. It'd be the same if James didn't exist. posted over a year ago.

	Clavicula picked No: She could have loved him but not in the same way he loved her. His love was so deep and never ended. I don't think that she would have loved him that much. posted over a year ago.

	sparkles3 picked Yes: of course. posted over a year ago.

	KitKatLex picked No: Nah. posted over a year ago.

	simpleplan picked No: They would still be friends. posted over a year ago.

	Thecharliejay picked No: No it was never meant to be posted over a year ago.

	karosama picked Yes: well, J.K. said once that if Severus hadn't been friends with the other death eaters and if they had stayed friends, she would have fallen in love with him (probably), so yes posted over a year ago. last edited over a year ago

	Popcornfan picked Yes: Maybe without James, Snape wouldn't had hang out with death eaters, and he would definetely had not called her a mudblood. posted over a year ago.

	Lackson4ever85 picked Yes: i think she love him alot,but she choose James over him. TRUE LOVE ALWAYS:) posted over a year ago.

	BrittanaForever picked Yes: I love Severus Snape and Lily Evans together, they are so freaking amazing!! SOULMATES!! posted over a year ago.

	lostandhp4ever picked No: But it wasn't James that caused their friendship to go downhill, it was Snape's love for the Dark Arts. Agreed! If the question would be: Do you think (If Snapes love for the Dark Arts hadn't existed but James had exist) Lily could have loved Severus in the same way he loved her? Than I would pick yes. posted over a year ago.

	Perfidia picked Yes: yes, I think they could have worked it out somehow! posted over a year ago.

	Hermine101 picked No: no posted over a year ago.

	ComoLoca picked Yes: Possibly. He wouldn't have been bullied as much so his "friendship" with the Future-Death-Eaters students wouldn't have seemed as important. The Levicorpus incident wouldn't have taken place. posted over a year ago.

	Miyuki-hime picked No: I doubt it posted over a year ago.