do you think that Kate Winslet would have been better Narcissa than Helen McCrory ? pesquisa Results - harry potter

What do you think? Place your vote!

(Placed your vote already? Remember to login!)

harry potter do you think that Kate Winslet would have been better Narcissa than Helen McCrory ?

61 fans picked:

No Helen is fine

67%

Yes Kate would've been perfect

33%

BellaLovett posted over a year ago

Make your pick! | next poll >>

18 comments

	BellaLovett picked Yes Kate would've been perfect: because Kate is way prettier than Helen besides she's a very good actress as we all know and she can do the role perfectly posted over a year ago.

	D_J267 picked No Helen is fine: Isn't she a bit young to play Narcissa though, besides I think Helens done a great job. posted over a year ago.

	BellaLovett picked Yes Kate would've been perfect: no Narcissa was supposed to look a bit young Helen looks way older than Helena Bonham Carter posted over a year ago.

	BlackHound picked No Helen is fine: Noooonoono...I just don't see Winslet in a Harry Potter film at all, let alone playing Narcissa Malfoy. Granted, Narcissa is the baby of the three sisters, it doesn't matter to me at all. posted over a year ago. last edited over a year ago

	BellaLovett picked Yes Kate would've been perfect: i always pictured Kate as Narcissa till the HBP movie came out :( posted over a year ago.

	ecpjll picked Yes Kate would've been perfect: yeah probably posted over a year ago.

	RealBenTennyson said: TBH, Kate would never have accpeted the role! posted over a year ago.

	BellaLovett picked Yes Kate would've been perfect: may be she would who knows and even so she'd have been a good Narcissa posted over a year ago.

	zanhar1 picked Yes Kate would've been perfect: But Helen is good too posted over a year ago.

	MarlenaLovett picked No Helen is fine: The only think I didn't like about Helen is they made her look a bit to old. I always thought Narcissa would be really young looking and really pretty. Other than that, she did good. posted over a year ago.

	Schnusch picked No Helen is fine: I think she's good posted over a year ago.

	NoEyeDeer picked Yes Kate would've been perfect: She would have made a brilliant Narcissa posted over a year ago.

	delamico picked Yes Kate would've been perfect: Most definitely. Kate looks a lot lot lot lot lot lot hell of a lot more like Narcissa. posted over a year ago.

	BellaLovett picked Yes Kate would've been perfect: ^she's how i pictured Cissy posted over a year ago.

	leanneheward picked No Helen is fine: i dont think kate is pretty, sorry. posted over a year ago.

	bri-marie picked No Helen is fine: I just don't see Kate as Narcissa. Helen looks a lot younger in RL. I don't know why they did her make-up that way -- it makes her look so much older than she really is. posted over a year ago.

	ninjakiwi picked No Helen is fine: Love helen posted over a year ago.

	Lackson4ever85 picked Yes Kate would've been perfect: Helen is awful actress posted over a year ago.