responda esta pergunta

harry potter Pergunta

Does anyone else think Harry would have been better off with Luna?

I absolutely amor Harry Potter, but one of the (few) things I don't like about it is Harry and Ginny. I mean, yes, she is better than Cho, but I just don't like her paired with Harry. To me, Ginny was boring and arrogant (as well as a slut). I guess it was because Harry wanted to live a normal life, and she's the only normal character. Also, she has a James Potter type of personality, while Harry has a Lily Evans type of personality (and he looks like James while she looks like Lily). But really, I didn't care for it.

I think Luna would have been much better for Harry. She is the only one in the books who can ever truly understand him, and he loves that about her. He would NEVER be bored with Luna (honestly, who would be?), and she can comfort him better than anyone. For example, after Sirius's death (RIP), Harry went into super-angst depression mode. Nobody could help him, not even Ron and Hermione. But when he spoke with Luna, he found that she was the only one he could speak to about it all, and she is the one who made him feel better.
*
me agree!you perfectly said everything!
haropuff95 posted over a year ago
 XDRoseLuvsHP posted over a year ago
next question »

harry potter Respostas

zelo said:
There are many reasons why I'm always torn when I'm asked this question. Yes, personally I do believe Luna and Harry belong together. In what I like to think is Harry's most gruesome ano at Hogwarts for him mentally is ano 5, when he first met Luna. She was the only one he could really talk to, because they both had that kind of "outsider" status, and their friendship was unique. But at the same time, they seem so good as friends that sometimes I don't think they are great together. I do amor Ginny and Harry together, probably mais than I ever loved Harry and Luna together. Harry and Luna have always been my favorito non-canon couple, though. I just don't know in the end, Harry and Luna? or Harry and Ginny? It's always this constant fight in my head Ginny VS Luna, and it never ends in triumph for either of them...
select as best answer
 There are many reasons why I'm always torn when I'm asked this question. Yes, personally I do believe Luna and Harry belong together. In what I like to think is Harry's most gruesome ano at Hogwarts for him mentally is ano 5, when he first met Luna. She was the only one he could really talk to, because they both had that kind of "outsider" status, and their friendship was unique. But at the same time, they seem so good as friends that sometimes I don't think they are great together. I do amor Ginny and Harry together, probably mais than I ever loved Harry and Luna together. Harry and Luna have always been my favorito non-canon couple, though. I just don't know in the end, Harry and Luna? or Harry and Ginny? It's always this constant fight in my head Ginny VS Luna, and it never ends in triumph for either of them...
posted over a year ago 
maryksand said:
I always thought tha Harry and Luna have to be together. Honestly, I saw book 5 as a hint that they will be a couple in book 6 and I was very disappointed when he was randomly paired with Ginny, who suddenly became a bitchy Mary Sue. That's just insane and immature that Ginny was his fangirl since 10 and then in the end she and Harry got married. It makes no sense and is the most unrealistic thing ever. Ginny had to mover on from Harry, which would be much mais logical. And Harry would have been happy with Luna. Not only Luna is an amazing, caring person who never judges people, but always tells truths (and imo Harry desperately needs someone like her around him, since he usually has people that are afraid to tell him the truth or people that expect from him too much and judge him por what they read in newspapers), but she also is someone who can understand Harry without words and make him feel better when even his best friends can't. After Sirius' death who was the only person who managed to make Harry feel a little better? Luna. She was the only one he could talk to about it. Who has an unique bound with Harry? Luna. They always shared a bound that Harry shared with no one else, but her. Who was the one to recognize Harry "just por that his expression" when he didn't even look like himself? Luna. Who was the one who "said it all for him" on Dobby's funeral? Luna. And finally, in the very end, who was the last person not from the Trio Harry talked to, a person who, again, understood him without him telling any word? Luna. On many, many levels they where perfect for each other.

select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
princesslullaby said:
I always thought Harry should be with Luna. She's so dynamically different from the other characters, and a great counterbalance to Harry. While all the other characters are similar in their seriousness and personality, she's the one Harry is totally different with . He feels calm and understood with her. He feels the same around Ginny as he does with Ron and Hermoine. I just feel like she is such a better match, though she's still not perfect.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
I completely agree!
maryksand posted over a year ago
LadyLilith said:
I wholeheartedly agree with you! They seem like they would be so good together. I personally don't get why Harry was paired with Ginny.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
Kind of random- but i amor ur ícone LadyLilith!!!
zelo posted over a year ago
*
XD lol sorry. I talked about this in a different place on this spot though, and I didn't feel like putting it again. Sorry. ^^;;
LadyLilith posted over a year ago
Jasminekyle said:
U apsolutly right! I agree with u!
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
totaldramacale said:
Harry & Ginny married 10 years after the Deathly Hallows, case closed
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
an error of 10 long years, poor harry xD
neko_roxas posted over a year ago
leanneheward said:
i always wanted this
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
CandyKat1314 said:
While i was leitura the book series i thought Harry should be a loner,but as soon as Luna appeared i was convinced she was going to end up with Harry.They were so perfect for each other that it was riduculous that Harry even thought about dating Ginny.Even if she wasn't a boring,crazy fangirl and didn't turn into a cadela, puta after book 4 she's still Rons' little sister!
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
Pensieve_Seeker said:
The HP series was written as a ring composition. In order for Harry to have started crushing on her in book 6 and end up with her in book 7, Luna would have had to have been noticed por him in book 1 and have a crush on him in book 2. The fact that she didn't even show up as a character until book 5 and Harry's first impression of her was "The girl beside the window looked up. She had straggly, waist-length, dirty-blonde hair, very pale eyebrows, and protuberant eyes that gave her a permamently surprised look. Harry knew at once why Neville had chosen to pass this compartment by. The girl gave off an aura of distinct dottiness" (OOTP, pg 185) rules her out as any kind of romantic interest for him.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
lililc said:
I don't thing that things about ginny (well,she is in fact arrogant,but not a slut)

I don't like the couple eiter but not beacuse ginny's character , it felt forced and of nowhere

I agree with you that it would had been better he end up with Luna , they had mais chemestry in one book than ginny and harry in all the seven
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
Flickerflame said:
1. Ginny isn't a slut. She's had three boyfriends throughout the series - the same amount as Hermione, and one mais than most of the other characters her age.
2. Ginny isn't the only normal character, and Harry didn't choose her because he wanted a normal life. He fell in amor with her. It's that simple.
3/. I wouldn't particularly say that Luna understands Harry better than anyone else. She simply could understand how he was feeling when he'd lost Sirius because she'd been bereaved too (and por the end of the story that is, unfortunately, something a lot of the characters now have in common).
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
johnkeppel said:
You need mais tha someone who is just comforting in order to have a good relationship. Ginny had fun with Harry, got his humor, made hum come out of his shell numorous times in oop, and..... and I'll say it again comforted him when Dumbedore died. Why does no one remember that Ginny had mais power than Hagrid to pull harry from Dumbledore's body
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
riffs101 said:
Luna Lovegood 100%
select as best answer
posted faz 2 meses 
next question »