what is you opinion on .. (spoiler deathly hallows movie)

okay people..you can't expect the filmes to be EXACTLY like the book! I've read DH like 7 times and I will notice if something little bit was changed but I don't go all : oh my gosh they changed it everything ruined.. sometimes the book way doesn't work on screen so they change. So on topic yes I do like the change because it's seems mais emotional and dramatic instead of Hedwig just drop dead in the cage.

The feelings in the book are devastating enough, it should just be left be!

It disappointments me - that scene was very symbolic and important and it really retracts from it all now that's it different.

It also makes me worried about what else they changed :x

I wish they would just stick to the book!
This makes me wonder how accurate the rest of the movie will be. Deathly Hallows is my favorito book and I want the movie to be good.

noooo! I amor that scene!!!!!! I don't want Harry to set her free!!!!!!!!!!! ugh! Stick to the book!

While it may seem mais appealing to some, TONS of Harry Potter fãs will be pissed with the change. JUST STICK TO THE FRICKEN' BOOK ALREADY! It's the last movie. Jeez.

It's... ok... but I think they should stick to the book. I hope they dont change too much for the other scenes.

I also want them to stick to the book but here's the way I see it

Either A. be stuck in a cage where she couldn't escape the battle and get killed without knowing what hit her

Or B. her to be free before the battle and die protecting the owner she loves

I don't know about you guys but I'm going with B

To me it looks awsome, awsome but sad i loved hedwig.

To me it looks great!
I like to stick to the book, but..here, i think its nice to have Hedwig coming to save Harry.According to me, it would be mais emotional.
That shows their bond and how much Hedwig loves Harry!
I don't get enough words when it comes to HP, especially DH, as i'm getting ready for a weeping competition.i think i'll be devastated when this ends!

wat the heck thats stupid IT HAS TO BE EXACTLY LIKE THE BOOK OR ELSE THE mover IS A WASTE UGH!!!!!!!!!!!

WHAT?! Tha-that's not cool. It needs to stay the same. It wouldn't make the movie better, just mais depressing and everyone will be angry.

What do you expect they had to do some changing they can't do everything por the book. The public doesn't allow that at all. You always have to do emballishing but I like it I thin it was a great touch that they did that.

I already prepared myself, that deathly hallows will not stick to the books at all, which is not a bad thing por all means, however, the attempts to differ from the books so far did not quite work out for David Yates as they often made things turn out absolutely illogical. As for the Hedwig pergunta in particular I've gotta say it's a bad idea. Deathly Hallows itself already puts Harry into a central position we have never seen before; he is the Chosen One, as well as the descendant of some important bloke. As if Aragorn carried the Ring or Anakin Skywalker was Yoda's great-great-great grandson. There's absolutely no need to express any further that Harry is in the center of everything. The wizarding world is at open warfare, there need to be accidental death too, no one is interested in yet another, the 101st self sacrifice for Harry. But of course - and unfortunately - I can't go and complain to Mr Yates, so go Hedwig, go! Just let it be a worthy ending to/for (I never know the right prep, sorry) the books!