What would happen if SNSD was only a 5 or 4 member group?

Five member group:
1. Seohyun - lead singer (maknae)
2. Tiffany - singer/rapper (visual)
5. Taeyeon - main singer (leader)
6. Yuri - rapper
7. Sooyoung - main dancer
I think they could be successful.

Four member group:
2. Tiffany - lead singer (leader)
4. Hyoyeon - main dancer
6. Yuri - rapper (maknae)
8. Jessica - main singer (visual)
I think they will be successful and each member will be able to shine.

1. Sunny
2. Yuri
5. Seohyun
6. Yoona
7. Sooyoung

Sunny and Seohyun could be main singers, Yuri and Sooyoung could be main dancers, and Yoona's the visual. I think they could be fairly successful, but nowhere near successful as SNSD now.

2. Yuri
4. Jessica
6. Yoona
8. Tiffany

Jessica and Tiffany- Main Singers
Yuri - Main Dancer
Yoona- Visual
Could be successful, but could be mais successful if mais members were added

5 member group:

1st: Seohyun
2nd: Jessica
5th: Taeyeon
6th: Yoona
7th: Yuri

This group would definitely popular, since the most popular members are in this group. This will basically like TTS, mais to vocal and little dance.

4 member:
2nd:Jessica
4th: Sooyoung
6th: Yoona
8th: Sunny

1st: Jessica (main vocalist)
2nd: Sunny (lead vocalist)
5th: Yoona (visual and lead dancer)
6th: Yuri (lead dancer)
7th: Hyoyeon (main dancer)

mais focus on dance but I think Jessica and Sunny are great singers so I think they will be successful :) Plus, YoonSic are popular with Asian fãs while HyoYulSun are popular with EuroAmerican fãs ^^

2nd: Sunny (lead vocal)
4th: Seohyun (main vocal)
6th: Yuri (lead dancer)
8th: Tiffany (main vocal)

Yuri will be either totally outshined cause of mais vocalist or she will get the most attention cause she is the only dancer. Either or Both can be the result :)

5 member group
my 1st- Sooyoung
my 2nd- Taeyeon
my 5th- Tiffany
my 6th- Seohyun
my 7th- Sunny

Sooyoung would be the main dancer, main rapper and vocalist.
Taeyeon would be the leader, main vocalist and probably the visual
Tiffany would be the lead vocalist and lead rapper
Seohyun would be the lead vocalist, maknae and probably the lead dancer
Sunny would be a vocalist

they would be pretty successful, imo (even though i don't think Sunny would add anything)




4 member group
my 2nd- Taeyeon´
my 4th- Yuri
my 6th- Seohyun
my 8th- Yoona

Taeyeon would be the leader and main vocalist
Yuri would be the main dancer, main rapper and vocalist
Seohyun would be the lead vocalist and maknae
Yoona would be the visual, lead dancer, lead rapper and sub vocalist

not sure about this one. there's not really any strong members apart from Taeyeon and Seohyun.



out in every group- Hyoyeon and Jessica

1. Hyoyeon (main dancer,visual,rapper)
2. Jessica (main Singer)
5. Seohyun (lead Singer, maknae)
6. Sunny (lead Singer, leader)
7. Yoona (lead dancer, rapper)

They could be succesful because they have great singers and dancer. I chose Hyo as the visual because she is the prettiest of SNSD (tha't my opinion) and I din't put Jessica as the leader because I think Sunny is a better leader.

2. Jessica (lead Singer)
4. Sooyoung (main dancer, maknae, rapper)
6. Sunny (lead Singer, leader, lead dancer)
8. Tiffany (main Singer, visual, rapper)

Tiffany is the visual because she is the prettiest (out of these) and Sunny is the leader again (the reasons are already in the first group) also Tiffany is the main Singer because i like her voice better that Jessica's. I put Sunny as the lead dancer because she can dance. I thnik that this group would not be as succesful as the first one but with good songs they could become something.

1. Yuri (main rapper and main dancer)
2. Tiffany (lead vocals and visual)
5. Seohyun (vocals , lead dancer and maknae)
6. Taeyeon (main vocals and leader)
7. Jessica (lead vocals)

2. Tiffany (lead vocals and visual)
4. Yoona (main dancer and main rapper)
6. Taeyeon (main vocals and leader)
8. Sunny (lead vocals and lead dancer)

1st : YoonA (Visual, Maknae, Lead dancer, Lead rapper)
2nd : Yuri (Main dancer)
5th : Jessica (Lead vocalist)
6th : Taeyeon (Main vocalist, Leader)
7th : Sooyoung (Dancer)

2nd : Yuri (Lead dancer, Visual)
4th : Seohyun (Lead vocalist, Maknae)
6th : Taeyeon (Leader, Main vocalist)
8th : Hyoyeon (Main dancer, Rapper)