responda esta pergunta

Critical Analysis of Twilight Pergunta

What do you think of 'Twimoms'?

I know a lot of people have problems with the Twilight Series.

e.g: Bella's relationship with Edward, a few of the characters' personalities, Stephenie Meyer's composição literária skills

Why do you think some mothers approve of leitura Twilight? Even some of them go link for it.
 What do you think of 'Twimoms'?
*
i think of twilight moms as sick i mean its sooooooooooooooo sick for a mother to be sooo obssessed with a fictional character nad then let her daughhter be too i mean how can she do that its like her daughter would be dreaming about edward he r mom would come a nd tell her not to coz he is hers they are totally sick!!!!!!
chagrin91 posted over a year ago
*
Wait...are we talking about the moms who are insane for Twilight or all moms who are fãs of Twilight? Now I'm a bit confused, I think I received the wrong idea...
sapherequeen posted over a year ago
*
^ Sorry, I should have been mais specific. I meant those Twimoms who are really mad/passionate about it. Those who force/'encourage' their kids to read it.
rachaelwsz posted over a year ago
 rachaelwsz posted over a year ago
next question »

Critical Analysis of Twilight  melhor resposta

Mermaid-Tail said:
I think it's insanity to be honest.
My main issue with Twilight is aiming it at a young audience meant readers weren't always mature enough to read it without being influenced, so you'd think older fãs would be ok with me, but not in this case, as I think there's a difference between Twilight fãs who are moms and 'Twimoms'. Twimoms reach the same level of obsession as the young fans, so it's even mais disturbing to me, because it makes them seem emotionally underdeveloped. They show behaviour they should have long grown out of, often with very little dignity. Their obsession is also a bad influence to young fans, because seeing grown ups show the same 'twi-hard' bad behaviour as them tells them it's a fine way to act. Also, it sends the message that things like the abusive relationship in the books is ok/healthy because young fãs can say 'it's not just an adolescent fantasy...my mom thinks that's a great amor too!'. Young fãs seeing older mais 'mature' women also swooning over that type of relationship behaviour validates it.

Also, let's look at the obvious. They are too old for Twilight obsessing. It's a juvenile tween book. It's one thing to enjoy something a little childish when you grow out of it's intended age group (I still like disney movies) but there's a big difference between enjoying and obsessing, and to obsess over a tween fad at that age is insane. To me, an older woman who reaches the level of obsession needed to be classed as a Twi-mom needs immediate medical attention. I honestly believe they need therapy.
I don't mean this about any older person who likes the series, just the ones obsessed enough to be called 'Twi-moms'

As for mothers who approve of the books, that's a personal issue I guess. If I had kids I wouldn't be ok with them leitura Twilight or aspiring to be like Bella, but if a parent has made themself familiar with it, and is either ok with it or feels their child will not be influenced, while I disagree and personally don't understand someone wanting their kids sent those messages it's not really my place to judge. I'd just hope they'd raised their kids well enough to read it without being influenced. If they have it's not an issue, and if they haven't then their problems go beyond Twilight.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
Uh, that seemed way less long ant ranty when I was typing it. No idea how I rambled on for so long, lol. oops :)
Mermaid-Tail posted over a year ago
*
I really get what your saying. I watched an interview with a Twi-Mom and I just felt embarassed for her. Her children looked horrified. Even her daughters. Their too old for obsessing, like you said, it's a tween book. Honestly...
Mrs-Grint posted over a year ago
*
Haha. :)
sleazy_weasley posted over a year ago
next question »

Respostas

Mongoose09 said:
they suck eggs
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
nuxi said:
I was linked to a disturbing discussion on the twilight moms forums once. A mother was posting this rant about how she was so angry and devastated and "heart-broken" upon discovering that her daughter didn't like twilight. She was atuação like there was something wrong with her and was basically asking the other moms how to fix her daughter. She even said she was going to take away her daughter's internet access in order to prevent her from visiting anti-twilight sites.

This is just an example of how when you isolate a group of slightly unhinged people in their own community, they catalyze each others' craziness until they become a mob of raving lunatics self-perpetuating their own mass delusions.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
That's disgusting. :/
katiecain posted over a year ago
*
oh my gosh.... i just read some of the comments and this is crazy! and i browsed the website a little and wow is all i have to say... this is freaky...
marglo posted over a year ago
*
That is so sad! That mom is complaining how her daughter doesn't appreciate "fine literature", while her daughter is quoting George Orwell! I feel so bad for that girl... :-(
MadamOcta13 posted over a year ago
kayleigh123_b said:
MY mom likes twilight but not in an over baring way she read it once and comes with me to the pictures to see it but thats where it stops. Dont know if i could cope with some of the twi-moms you guys are reporting :D x

select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
Then your mom is a normal, sane, Twilight fan, not a Twilight mom ;) You're lucky you can share Twilight with her
Plenilunio posted over a year ago
*
Yeah, that's how my mom is too. She has read the books once, and she takes me to see the movies. That's all. I couldn't deal if my mom was a Twilight mom.
Ashley-Alice posted over a year ago
*
My mom wanted to see the movie because she thought it would be a good vampire movie; it had nothing to do with the whole Edward thing (she didn't like the movie, por the way).
MadamOcta13 posted over a year ago
ravendru said:
that is just freaky why why why i don't freaking understand some people.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
Nicoleandjames said:
I think that they just want to fit in with there daughters, you kow like have a better reltionship with them, have something in common with them
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
ILuvSweeneyTodd said:
DISGUSTING!!!

and mums are SUPPOSED to set an example to their daughters!!! >:(
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
Free_Spirit said:
lol, kinda freaky to me if my mum turned into one. But to some people thats just it, they've lived in the real world for such a long time, that they have found a book that represents the dreams they probably had when they were little
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
sapherequeen said:
Well, I'm going to admit that I disagree with some people here (the ones who are being offensive).

Not all parents who like Twilight are fanatics of the series. They may like the books as any other sane person would. I know a grandmother who liked the Twilight series, and to me she seems like any other strong, normal woman who raised her children to be good, sociable, well-liked adults.

Why should someone's liking or disliking a series affect their parenting skills?

I'm not trying to be harsh or offensive. This just simply puzzles me.

I highly doubt someone's opinion on a book series turns them into a bad mom.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
I agree, except when they get all upset because their daughter doesn't like Twilight and thinks Edward's a stalker. The link's up there somewhere ^ :)
katiecain posted over a year ago
*
I wasn't refering to all mothers that like twilight, just the particular online community which encourages mothers that literally obessessing over Twilight and a 17 ano old boy is not a bad thing.
nuxi posted over a year ago
MadamOcta13 said:
I think it's sick, disgusting, and those women need to get a life! I mean really, I can understand wanting to see the movie or even read the book because of a good vampire story (which is something I don't think Twilight is, but I'm just saying), but being OBSESSED with it is ridiculous! These women are obviously drawn to what the whole book's about: romantic Edward and/or Jacob. It's disgusting! These characters that they're drooling over could be their own kids! And not only that: aren't these women supposed to be married...? There are plenty of vampire romance ADULT books out there! Twilight is directed to teens looking to fall in amor with some fictional character-THERE OWN AGE! Twilight Moms: HAVE SOME SENSE, GROW UP, AND GET A LIFE!!!
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
next question »