black butler

responda esta pergunta

black butler Pergunta

Is Grell a boy or girl?

In the anime, I hear characters refer to Grell as male AND female. I think Grell is a girl, but I dunno.
*
its canon that grell is a trans* female. she was born a he but wants to be female and is a female. ITS CANON IN THE mangá LOOK : link
XxxOliverxxX posted over a year ago
*
Actually if you think of it, Grell is just a perverted male. If you listen and watch season 1&2, it's obvious Grell is a gay Sebastian lover. But I can't blame him, Sebastian is quite fetching.
ciels_wife2020 posted over a year ago
Hiding 2 comments... click to show.
*
Actually after leitura mais in the mangá it appears that grell is trans women
ProKiller288 posted over a year ago
 Mokachino posted over a year ago
next question »

black butler  melhor resposta

NightFrog said:
She's a woman in a man's body, I guess you can say. She's transgendered, so while she's one gender physically, she's another gender mentally- personally, I think what she thinks mentally is mais important and mais real. I really wish people can understand this though, people act as if transgendered people aren't real or are diseased..
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
I ask this not to be difficult, but honestly curious. How do you know? I like most don't know that much about the transgendered, but unlike most I wish to understand.
AmyMeowCat posted over a year ago
*
^Ha, sorry I'm responding 2 months later. The creator of the mangá stated that Grell was transgendered. And that's fine, for some it's something difficult to grasp, and that's fine as long as there's acceptance. The way Grell's gender is debated on sometimes just vexes me, since it's being transgendered is something very real, and other transgendered people are also described as just 'thinking' they're another gender, or that they 'want to.' Your genitals and physical anatomy can't define who you are mentally, it's not black and white. ..At least, that's just my input. xD
NightFrog posted over a year ago
Hiding 2 comments... click to show.
*
Actually after leitura mais in the mangá it appears that grell is trans women
ProKiller288 posted over a year ago
next question »

Respostas

tyger002 said:
Boy
Here's proof from Season 2
 select as best answer
Boy Here's proof from Season 2
posted over a year ago 
*
not all women have breasts ???? they are known as trans* females. same with boys . some boys have boobs because they are trans* males
XxxOliverxxX posted over a year ago
*
No Oliver. biologically, women have breasts and men do not. It's natural. Anything else is false.
kopopoilo posted over a year ago
*
its a fucking shame some ppl are so close-minded
zachisprettygay posted over a year ago
*
Actually after leitura mais in the mangá it appears that grell is trans women
ProKiller288 posted over a year ago
Black-Maid- said:
Grell is definitely a boy who has fallen in amor with Sebastian.ever since then,he's been considering himself as a girl and has been atuação like a girl.
 select as best answer
Grell is definitely a boy who has fallen in amor with Sebastian.ever since then,he's been considering himself as a girl and has been atuação like a girl.
posted over a year ago 
*
notice how he's flat chested?
Black-Maid- posted over a year ago
*
Some women are that way!
viktoriya773 posted over a year ago
Hiding 4 comments... click to show.
*
Actually after leitura mais in the mangá it appears that grell is trans women
ProKiller288 posted over a year ago
Harpaw8 said:
Grell is guy :3
 select as best answer
Grell is guy :3
posted over a year ago 
*
No grell is a trans* woman
XxxOliverxxX posted over a year ago
*
I personally use male pronouns when referring to Grell but...I can understand where you guys are coming from
iiGrim_Alexia posted over a year ago
*
Actually after leitura mais in the mangá it appears that grell is trans women
ProKiller288 posted over a year ago
alekdabutler said:
Grell is a Pre-operation Male-to-female transexual.
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
actually wrong. the correct term is transgender :)
XxxOliverxxX posted over a year ago
roxindreamer said:
Grell is a trans* woman. Please respect her pronouns.
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
YOU ARE THE 1 DECENT PERSON HERE ILY . YES GRELL IS A TRANS* WOMAN
XxxOliverxxX posted over a year ago
DementedPalkia said:
HE'S A GUY DUMBFUCK!
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
SHES A GIRL YOU DUMBFUCK
XxxOliverxxX posted over a year ago
*
HE'S A GUY, OLIVER YOU DUMBFUCK
kopopoilo posted over a year ago
*
SHES A GIRL SO CHIL OUT AS+ND STOP ARGUIIIIING
AshieFlashie posted over a year ago
*
Actually after leitura mais in the mangá it appears that grell is trans women
ProKiller288 posted over a year ago
Danndy said:
Male
Look on the wikia
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
exactly
kopopoilo posted over a year ago
*
Shes a girl
AshieFlashie posted over a year ago
*
Transgender
AshieFlashie posted over a year ago
dontmindmeyo said:
the amount of transphobia in the respostas to this pergunta makes me extremely upset
grell is a girl and is also the queen of my coração shes great and should not be called with the wrong pronouns like a lot of people here are doing and that makes me extremely disappointed in the black butler fandom.
she is a girl. her body does not make her a boy. her mind, who she believes she is, and her dream of getting a sex change, makes her 100% female.
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
boohooo you snowflake. I'll be as transphobic as I like.
kopopoilo posted over a year ago
*
His body most definitley makes him a man.
kopopoilo posted over a year ago
*
Kopopolio, you are toxic. She's a girl so stfu
AshieFlashie posted over a year ago
aloisatrancy said:
grell is a MALE but, he acts like a girl and hes gay!!
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
SammyIsAMoose47 said:
Ok, Here Is My Opinion On Grell. If You Refer To Grell As Male, That's Fine, If You Refer To Grell As Female, That's Fine. Honestly, I Don't Think There Is Really Any Proof Or Evidence To Grell Sutcliff's Gender. No Matter How Many Pictures You Search, And No Matter How Much Research And Commenting You Do, Personally, I Don't Believe That This Contoversy Will Ever End Within Our Fandom. Though Everyone Could And Is Able To Hold A Good Argument Within This Contoversy. Everyone Has Great Reasons To Which Gender Grell Should Be Refered To. But The Point Is, Grell Is Grell. And We Should All Just Remember That No Matter What Gender You Refer To. Grell Is Lovable, Crazy, And Great In Everyway. And If Grell Is Male Or Female, There Is No Doubt That Grell Will Always Be Loved. ☺️
Please Don't Hate On My Comment!
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
Actually after leitura mais in the mangá it appears that grell is trans women
ProKiller288 posted over a year ago
kopopoilo said:
He's a man who pretends to act like a woman because he wants that demon D
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
Thanl you.
suckmy posted over a year ago
*
Shes a girl
AshieFlashie posted over a year ago
*
Actually after leitura mais in the mangá it appears that grell is trans women
ProKiller288 posted over a year ago
Kikochan12 said:
It's known that Grell is trans women but it's shown ONLY in Manga. What about calling this beautiful creature They/Them for know or just stop ,Yelling' at each other for our opinion?
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
Alchemistlover said:
i believe he's a boy but wants to be a girl and is gay.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
no shit sherlock :))
ValkyrieCaine posted over a year ago
*
you both are wrong she is a transgender female
XxxOliverxxX posted over a year ago
*
Actually after leitura mais in the mangá it appears that grell is trans women
ProKiller288 posted over a year ago
grell571 said:
Grell sutcliff is a man he acts woman because he believes Sebastian is into women and he looks pretty sexy
 select as best answer
Grell sutcliff is a man he acts woman because he believes Sebastian is into women and he looks pretty sexy
posted over a year ago 
*
BASSY!!
ValkyrieCaine posted over a year ago
*
just so you know he started looking like a girl before he meet sebastian. He looks like a girl because of William
UNLIMITEDXD posted over a year ago
*
wrong grell is a trans* woman
XxxOliverxxX posted over a year ago
*
Actually after leitura mais in the mangá it appears that grell is trans women
ProKiller288 posted over a year ago
QueenRed said:
Grell is a guy, I think XD
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
Thank you
suckmy posted over a year ago
*
Shes a girl, trans to be exact
AshieFlashie posted over a year ago
*
Actually after leitura mais in the mangá it appears that grell is trans women
ProKiller288 posted over a year ago
springtrout said:
Grell is a guy he's just gay (yes they're are gay animê characters)
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
Though guy on guy action is um..... how am i going to say i amor it.........I like Yuri better because well, im into chicks so yeah.....
ValkyrieCaine posted over a year ago
*
like Harley
EeveeOak500 posted over a year ago
Hiding 3 comments... click to show.
*
Actually after leitura mais in the mangá it appears that grell is trans women
ProKiller288 posted over a year ago
ValkyrieCaine said:
Grell is a transvestite. Though he is male, he has the spirit and mind of a female.

hope you find helpful!
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
she is not a transvestite ?!?!?! you clearly can't tell the difference between transgender , transexual ,and transvestite
XxxOliverxxX posted over a year ago
*
He doesn't have "the spirit and mind of a female", he's just gay.
kopopoilo posted over a year ago
*
Grell is trans. She is a girl
AshieFlashie posted over a year ago
EeveeOak500 said:
I think Boy
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
mizuki_is_mine_ said:
Male
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
wrong she is transgener
XxxOliverxxX posted over a year ago
*
*gender
XxxOliverxxX posted over a year ago
*
100% male
kopopoilo posted over a year ago
*
Girl
AshieFlashie posted over a year ago
UNLIMITEDXD said:
Grell is male but is said to be bisexual since he loved madam red, sebastian, william and the under taker
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
she is a trans* female a.k.a was born male but wanted to be female so is trans*
XxxOliverxxX posted over a year ago
*
100% male
kopopoilo posted over a year ago
*
GIRL
AshieFlashie posted over a year ago
natasha1830 said:
from the first time that i saw his pic on google images, i thought he was a girl. i mean just look at it this way-his hair is as long as a girls, his eyes almost look like girls eyes(with the eyelashes), he's crazy over sebastian or as he would call him "Bassy". and some of the pics that i saw on goolge images, make him look like exactly like a girl!! thts just my opinion on him.
 select as best answer
from the first time that i saw his pic on google images, i thought he was a girl. i mean just look at it this way-his hair is as long as a girls, his eyes almost look like girls eyes(with the eyelashes), he's crazy over sebastian or as he would call him "Bassy". and some of the pics that i saw on goolge images, make him look like exactly like a girl!! thts just my opinion on him.
posted over a year ago 
*
Bassy? You mean Sebby?
fandomfan posted over a year ago
*
yeah i always called him sebby, but there are two things u can call sebastian. sebby always stuck with me, and it still does
natasha1830 posted over a year ago
Hiding 3 comments... click to show.
*
Shes a girl
AshieFlashie posted over a year ago
perple123 said:
Grell is a boy, you can tell por his facial shape, female characters usually have a mais round face.
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
grell is a female. she was born a he and she wants to be refered to as a woman so SHE is a woman a.k.a trans* women
XxxOliverxxX posted over a year ago
*
Exactly, he has the body of a man, it's extremely obvious.
kopopoilo posted over a year ago
XxxOliverxxX said:
grell was physically born a male but she wants to be female so she is known as a trans* female. she is not gay for "bassy" she wants to be a woman and IS a women.
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
No, he's just a gay man.
kopopoilo posted over a year ago
jessamyn1998 said:
Grell is a girl but looks like a guy. In episode 5 she says, "You just went after a lady's face! You're a fiend!" So Grell is a girl.
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
No, he likes to pretend to be a girl since he is a gay guy and he thinks that is what will get that D.
kopopoilo posted over a year ago
Ciel_demon said:
Girl. She has mentioned from time to time that she is a lady. Although it is possible that Grell is a cruz dresser
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
He pretends that he's a woman because he's a gay guy.
kopopoilo posted over a year ago
_MadamRed_ said:
Grell WAS a boy, but he is trans so now a girl, you can tell por his face structure and voice that he was a boy.





 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
nah he just a gay man
kopopoilo posted over a year ago
angleef said:
It's a she
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
*he
kopopoilo posted over a year ago
Lokinne said:
Grell is a trans*female. She has a male body but tends to refer to herself as a girl or a woman.
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
egyptprincess7 said:
Grell is trans women. Please don't call her a he. She's a she.

Wow guys wow. She's a she. So no Grell isn't gay considering that she's a she and loves Sebastian (a guy) so stop saying she's a he and respect her pronouns.
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
ciels_wife2020 said:
Grell is actually, mainly a girl. According to book #12 or #13, Grell mentioned forgetting to put on makeup for a dancing metaphore from what I've read. I may be wrong, but I'm pretty sure.
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
Acacia_Brinleyy said:
he's a transgender
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
BlackCookie said:
girl
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
hetalianstella said:
She identifies as a woman so therefore she is a woman.
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
dlvdog said:
Transgender. She was a male but wanted to be female. c:
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
CielElsaGrell said:
Grell is a guy that dresses like a girl. Reason being because it is only the part he plays as a grim reaper. Also he is gay can't blame him. Plus most people amor Sebastian anyway so that's why.
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
Reona72 said:
boy
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
KirikoRin said:
He's 'biologicially' a dude but he's feminine and gay. Yaoi...xD
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
earlgreyanime said:
Grell is a trans* woman ^-^.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
AnimeGodKarkat said:
The easiest way to explain it is that grell is a transgender. Not that he was a man before he met Sebby, but that he just thinks that hes a girl. Theres nothing wrong with that, we just need to simply state, that yes. Phisically grell is a man, if thats what your wondering. But mentally grell considers himself a female, so thats what most call him.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
adarableangeles said:
He is male but people say he is female for me I think they say grell I female because how he acts like a female or a girl. MY OPINION is that grell is male.
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
Animegirl204 said:
Well this is the same as Crona from Soul Eater where it depends on the situation they're in so you'll never know



 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
AnimeGirlLove said:
It is believed that Grell is gay. Technically he is male, however he wishes to get a female. in episode he says," Do you think I'm the kind of woman you can just buy with money ?"
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
KaliPhantomhive said:
Actually it's a Black Butler flaw or just a change. In one of her/his first appearance Grell is shown in a somewhat "showy" outfit with breasts and is refered to as she. A few episodes later Grell is flat chested and is refered to as he. I believe Grell was female but after many fãs making the mistake of Grell's gender they changed Grell's gender or the studios got lazy and accidenty changed Grell's gender.
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
HoloTrancy said:
girl
Yes Grell states it himself
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
fire_glitch6 said:
i am an expert.....grell is agender because flat cheast for 1 and 2 grell calls himslef a girl and a boy exampale;grell said that "she" was a flor meant for acting, grell also shai that "bassy and him would be the gay romeo and Juliet
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
AloisTrancy01 said:
He's a boy
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
grell-sutcliff0 said:
Grell is a female
 select as best answer
Grell is a female
posted over a year ago 
*
He is a male. Fuck you
suckmy posted over a year ago
Cypher136 said:
It could be that reapers are all agen dear and just express themselves as they see fit so in Grell's case their personality seems to be feminine and their physical appearance is somewhat masculine.
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
I'm pretty sure they can just look in their pants and figure it out from there
kopopoilo posted over a year ago
sasukechidori said:
How would any one know unless he or she or it was alive and you looked in his pants but whos to say grim reaper's have a gender and i am just simply one hell of a Butler and my real name is subastion 👿👿👿👿

 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
WitheredArtist said:
For those who are wondering, Grell is transgender. Meaning she is a guy, but acts/dresses/has the traits of a girl, but in all technicalities, Grell is indeed a boy
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
Mikasa_Senpia97 said:
Grill is boy who has long hair and he is gay but he wants to be a girl.:3
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
Blackbutler10 said:
Shell is a man, but Grell wants to be identified as a woman (in season 2 of black butler Grell says "I am the queen of all reapers") as she appears like a man but she wants to be a woman
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
Wolfette_Otaku said:
Grell is indeed male. He is gay and transgender. He does use the words to refer to himself and "she" and "her", instead of using "him" and "he"
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
suckmy said:
If y'all think that my BB Grell has a vagina, then y'all dumb asses better look that shit up. PRONOUNS BICTH. Pay. Fucking. Attention. When. Watching. Anime. Headass. I'm gonna get hate for this, but idgaf. He is not a female inside a male's body, he is *gay*. Get it? He has a dick and wants the dick. It's honestly not that fucking hard. Thank you fellow otakus/weeaboos/fujoshis/fudanshis and have a beautiful day.
select as best answer
If y'all think that my BB Grell has a vagina, then y'all dumb asses better look that shit up. PRONOUNS BICTH. Pay. Fucking. Attention. When. Watching. Anime. Headass. I'm gonna get hate for this, but idgaf. He is not a female inside a male's body, he is *gay*. Get it? He has a dick and wants the dick. It's honestly not that fucking hard. Thank you fellow otakus/weeaboos/fujoshis/fudanshis and have a beautiful day.
posted over a year ago 
pop-a-girl said:
Grell is a boy and a girl only because he cossplay
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
Cam2018 said:
He is a reaper. He is a being that is beyond gender
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
Kohagura said:
Yana Toboso herself has stated that Grell is "Okama", which does NOT actually mean transgender, but is the Japanese word for a "gay man OR male crossdresser", and used only to describe men. It's mais used to describe a "character personality" mais than a person's actual identity. In Grell's case, it refers to him being the flamboyantly gay man character.

On the other hand, the common Japanese word for transwoman is "Newhalf" (ニューハーフ), or mais politely and proper "Transgender" written in Japanese (トランス系 or トランスジェンダー).

Yana Toboso has never used actual transgender terms to describe Grell.
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
iiGrim_Alexia said:
I support LGBTQ+ people (That includes transgenders too!!) but if I am being completely honest here, I personally use male pronouns, if you do not agree, that is your choice to make, not mine! <3
I think that ANY pronouns are okay for Grell, let's just all put our opinions on Grell's pronouns behind and all just call him whatever what feels mais comfortable to you.
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
AshieFlashie said:
She is a GIRL. GIRLLLLLLLLLLL jeez people.
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
ProKiller288 said:
Actually after leitura mais in the mangá it appears that grell is trans women
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
Ankiiakiaaau said:
I think grell is boy
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
Peachkey said:
It has been confirmed that Grell is a female, so Grell a female/girl
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
Jacket123 said:
I think grell is pretending to be a girl just to get Sebastian attention but also in black Butler grell gets pregnant or is that just fake?

 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
kokichi-simp said:
Grell is a transgender woman
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
next question »
Cookies help us bring you Fanpop. By using Fanpop, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More Got It!